← Back to summary

Full Transcript

Board Advances Multiple Heritage Designations - 16 Nov 26

Toronto · November 17, 2026

Good morning, Adam. >> Good morning. Can you hear me? >> Yes, I can, but I can't see you. >> Yes, I'm working on that right now. I'm trying to figure out what's going on. Hold on a moment. Huh? Why am I so blurry? That's weird. There you go. >> Oh, I can see you now. Thank you. Madam Chair, Good morning. My name is Julia Ray and I am the chair of the Toronto Preservation Board. The clerk has confirmed that we have quorum. So I will now call meeting one of the Toronto Preservation Board to order. Welcome everyone. This is a hybrid meeting with some members, staff, and public attending in person and others connecting by video conference over the WebEx platform or calling in. This meeting is also being livereamed online at youtube.com/orronto city council live. Because we are meeting in person and remotely, we ask for your patience with any delays and technical issues. If you are registered to speak at today's meeting, please listen for me to call your name and I will call speakers in the order they appear on the list. The list of speakers can be viewed online by visiting the Toronto Preservation Board at toronto.ca/countsil and clicking the speakers box for today's meeting. I would like to request that staff and invited participants as well as all observers joining remotely keep their video turned off unless they need to speak or answer questions. This will make it easier for me as chair to see the members as we debate and vote on the agenda items. Members, for quorum purposes and participation in the meeting, it is important for you to keep your cameras on. I also ask that your microphones are muted unless you wish to speak or to question staff or speak to an item. To ensure we have an efficient meeting with the board members having an equal opportunity to ask questions or to speak on an item, I will run the timer for five minutes. Members will have up to five minutes each to ask questions of staff and speak on an item. As a reminder, motions need to be moved at the beginning of a member's speaking time and please submit and approve your motions by email. Staff are available at htpb toronto.ca to help with motions. If members wish to speak on an item, please raise your hand or unmute your mic and indicate your intention to speak and I will create a speaker list. When voting on an item or a motion, I ask members to raise your hand to indicate your vote. If there is a recorded vote, you will be asked to state if you are in favor or opposed. Members, the clerk has provided all agenda materials on toronto.ca/counsel. Although we may be meeting in different locations today, the preservation board would like to acknowledge that the land we are meeting on is the traditional territory of many nations, including the Missagas of the Credit, the Anesnab, the Chippoa, the Hneson, and the Wendat peoples, and it is now home to many diverse First Nations, Inuit, and Matei peoples. We also acknowledge that Toronto is covered by Treaty 13 with the Missagas of the Credit. At this moment, I will ask if there are any declarations of interest under the Municipal Conflict of Interest Act. If you do have an interest, please raise your hand or unmute your mic and indicate the item number and the nature of the interest. Seeing none, may I have a motion to confirm the minutes from our July 23rd, 2026 meeting? Paul, thank you so much. All those in favor, please raise your hands. And that has been confirmed and carried. So before we review today's agenda, I'd like to briefly clarify the process regarding staff reports and presentations. The reports for each item contain the information and recommendations before the board and form the basis for the board's decisions. We make our decisions based on the agenda materials and not presentations. Um and the presentations are provided as a courtesy to highlight key information and assist with discussion. We have six item on today's agenda for consideration. I urge board members to hold those items only if they wish to ask questions or staff um or have discussion. So we'll now proceed with the agenda review. Our first item is PB 1.1 8 Arnold Avenue notice of intention to designate a property under part 4 section 29 of the Ontario Heritage Act. There is no presentation but staff are available to answer questions. Would anybody like to hold this item? Adam. Thank you. Moving on to PB 2.2, 106 Beverly Street, notice of intention to designate a property under part 4, section 29 of the Ontario Heritage Act. Again, no presentation, but staff are available for questions. Would anybody care to hold this item? Adam, thank you. The next is PB 1.3 66 Gerard Street East, notice of intention to designate a property under part 4, section 29 of the Ontario Heritage Act. Would anybody care to hold this item? Adam any uh PB 1.470 Gerard Street East notice of intention to designate a property under part 4 section 29 of the Ontario Heritage Act. Would anybody like to hold this item? Seeing none, would anybody like to move? >> Hello. Hello, Madam Chair. I'm trying to hold the item. Yes. >> Item held. PB 1.51 19 Dawn Ridge Drive. Notice of intention to designate a property under part 4 section 29 of the Ontario Heritage Act. No presentation on this item, but staff are available for questions. Would anybody care to hold this item? Mitch. Thank you. And then finally, PB 1.6137 Queen Street West demolition and new construction on a designated heritage property under part five, section 42 of the Ontario Heritage Act. Approval. Jeff, you're going to hold the item. All right. Back to the top. So PB 1.18 Arnold Avenue. We have no speakers on any of the items today. So we'll move directly into asking questions of staff. Adam, you held the item. And Jeff, do you have a question first? >> Yes. >> Yeah. It's in five of the six items all relate to buildings that are 1870s early Toronto. um you know substantial construction in the city of Toronto in the 1870s. I'm just wondering in the context of of of the schedule of Toronto Preservation Board, is there a plan to that this meeting was the one dealing with 1870s buildings? Uh like where are we going with this stuff? Because we're losing the listing status and only a couple of months. So I'm just wondering what the plan here is. Was it a a definite plan to bring 1870s to this meeting or or is it or is there some other plan? >> Uh through the chair, if you will remember Jeff uh way back when we gave an understanding of the prioritization uh process and criteria that we were using for bill 23, >> there were two sets of periods of time that uh were understood to be underrepresented uh in terms of designations. They were the pre-1870s and then the post 1960s. So we have been working away on both of those areas plus others as we've been able and we have already sent a number of the 1870s reports to this board. They have they all indicate that they're part of the bill 23 project. I believe Paul this is the last one of the last ones that we've done. Uh yeah, the 1870s work is largely wrapping up. There are three outstanding um that need to that are just working their way through the end of the uh research evaluation process. So you can expect to see one more at the next meeting as we move into the 1860s or sorry post 1960s. >> Um sorry >> then be bringing forward the other periods. I mean what and are you going to present a plan to the board with moving forward >> uh through the chair? I think the overall plan for bill 23 is kind of outside the scope of this particular report. Um and we will be bringing forward a report in January that summarizes all the work that we're doing as well as uh how we intend to address things into the future. >> Okay, good. Thank you. >> Pulling things back to 8 Arnold Avenue. Mitch, is your question about the property? >> It is. >> Okay. Um, Mitch, and then but I I' I've jumped ahead. Adam, did you have a question? >> Yes. Um, Madame Chair, I actually have a few questions and I'm I'm just trying to determine which to ask in the Gerard properties and which to ask of this property. I'll actually start with the ones pertinent to this exact property here. Um, was this uh I have three questions pertaining to this Mount Dennis one. >> Okay. Was this property listed or is this an immediate designation report? >> It's been listed. >> Yes. Good morning through the chair. It was listed May 20th, 2026. >> Thank you. >> Next question. >> Was this uh Thank you, Madam Chair. Um, was this identified through the Mount Dennis uh heritage survey that Heritage Planning began undertaking around 2016 uh 2017? >> Yes, it was. As the report states, it was one of the properties identified. >> Thank you. >> And your last question? >> I realize my last question is more of a comment, Madam Chair, rather than the question itself. Thank you. >> All right, Mitch. >> Hello, Madam Chair. and uh it's nice to see you all again. Uh I did read the report that you shared with us. Thank you. And I noticed that um that it was listed and also that um there's imminent threat to its very existence. I think the report mentioned that the owner would like to demolish the building. Can staff speak a little bit first of all to the condition of the home? Is it a private residence? Is it um is its character still intact? And what is its character? haven't really eyeballed it very closely. And secondly, um can they speak to the imminent uh threat of demolition? [clears throat] >> Yes, through the chair. Um as the report notes, uh demo uh application was made to Toronto building, but um we have not received an application through the Herage Act, excuse [clears throat] me. Um, per the condition of the building, uh, given given its age and given that there hasn't been a lot done to the building, um, the building maintains its integrity. Um, but it it is a it is an 1870s building. So, um, undoubtedly there are some issues with condition. >> I would like to follow up with that um to through the chair. We ourselves do not have any report received uh in regards to the condition of the building. Uh so uh that would be something that would be part of the information as a heritage impact assessment should they apply under the Ontario Heritage Act. This is all still emerging this this issue at this time. We had already indicated through our listing earlier in the year that the interest of this property. So uh thanks to the board adopting that report and are recommending that adoption in council we're well positioned for dialogue with the property owner. >> Are there other question related to the designation itself recognizing that before us is the heritage value under the act and whether it's there. Mitch >> I noticed in the report that it the building the home the [clears throat] structure ticks three of the nine boxes. Could staff um elaborate on the three of the nine boxes that are ticked? >> Yes. Again, um it has value for person value associated with George Marshall, the [clears throat] builder. It yields information about the historical settlement of the area. And finally, does design physical value? >> Thanks. >> Are there other questions? >> Seeing none, we move into discussion amongst ourselves. Adam. >> Um, thank you, Madam Chair. Um, it's delightful to see um an Ontario house being designated. This is some real uh homegrown Ontario architecture with this particular style of building. certainly with renewed interest as well in the recent with the recent book published on this architectural style. Um that being said, the pres Toronto Eastro Community Preservation Panel um would like to have a discussion with City of Toronto staff around their application of the Ontario Heritage Act on several other Ontario House properties in the city of Toronto and several properties which our panel has flagged for potential heritage status and which were identified as not um being pursuant for designation. So, we're concerned around inconsistencies of how this style is being applied for designation, but look forward to continuing to discuss with staff and are very grateful to see this property being designated. >> Thank you. Are there other comments, Germaine, to the report before us? Seeing none, I have a staff report with recommendations. Would anybody like to move the recommendations in the report? Paul, thank you very much. All those in favor, please. And that carries. Moving on now to PB uh 2.2. Again, no speakers, so we'll move directly into questions of staff. This is the 106 Beverly Street property and the notice of intention to designate questions for staff on this item. Adam. >> Uh thank you, Madam Chair. I'm actually just trying to pull the um the agenda item up here on um the preservation board agenda. Unfortunately, one of the links was frozen for a moment. Um, [clears throat] were st Thank you, manager. Were staff able to identify any of James Gran's original drawings of this building in their research to locate any of these original drawings? >> Hello, I'm Adrien Gable, heritage planner. Uh, through you, chair. Uh, thanks Adam for the question. These all of these 1870s uh bill 23 reports were prepared for us with the help of uh consultant work to answer questions about specific sources that were pulled or archival materials. I would I could refer to the uh sources list, but I think the best thing would be to um confer with the consultant. I don't know offhand which archival materials um were sourced or which weren't. Other questions? Adam. >> Um, thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you, Adrian. Is the veranda structure, which is um I believe originally an open veranda, but since enclosed original to this building >> through you, chair. The veranda uh was part of the early 20th century modifications made to uh the former Estston House as part of its conversion into Georgina House. These modifications included the veranda, the rear wing, interior modifications, and the Osler wing. They were completed between 1909 and 1914 by architect Eden Smith. Uh, and that includes the veranda. So, no, it wasn't original to the original. It wasn't part of the original structure. >> Other questions? Seeing none, discussion amongst ourselves. Adam. >> Um, thank you, Madam Sher. I'm grateful for staff for uh providing clarification on the history of that ver. Earlier this year, I had the opportunity to code lead walked past this house and during that walk, there was discussion of how the Esta family was from Bermuda and questions about whether the ver was modeled after those in Bermuda or not. So, I do appreciate the clarification that it was an early 20th century Eden Smith design. Thank you. >> Other comments, discussion? >> Seeing none, I have a staff report with recommendations before me. Would anybody like to move those recommendations? Mitch, thank you so much. All those in favor, please. And that carries. Moving on to PB 1.3 66 Gerard Street East and the notice of intention to designate. Again, no speakers. Um, do we have any questions for staff on this one? >> Mitch, >> thanks. Um, [clears throat] that's the northwest corner, is it? Church and Gerard sort of anchors that corner uh with the buff brick. I wonder to what extent has it been modified over the years from its original um construction. >> Hello, Adrien Gamble again, Heritage Planner through you, chair. Uh, thank you Mitch for the question. Uh, 66 Gerard Street East um has had some modifications over time. It was constructed circa 1855 and it was originally three attached brick house form buildings which were known historically as 62 64 and 66 street east. However, uh further into a few decades later, um the building underwent some uh interventions including uh the addition of a 1910 rear edition which adds a street wall along Church Street. >> Thanks. >> Are there other questions, Adam? Thank you, Madam Chair. I have um three to five questions pertaining to this site. Um and I I want to preface this with thanking uh staff and and the consultant for their report and for including the 2SLGBTQ history of this site in the report. It's very important to have that. Um my my first question it pertains more broadly to this site and neighborhood as a whole, but this property sits on buried Moss Park Creek, one of the lost rivers in Toronto. Um does heritage planning have a cultural daylighting policy for reports including properties on or adjacent to lost rivers? the designation um before us the notice of intention or is that more um because if you're talking about daylighting that doesn't have anything to do with >> cultural daylighting >> but that doesn't have >> and it would be part of the site's history >> how would I don't really want to get into an argument here but we have before us we're looking at the merits of designation >> does cultural daylighting contribute under the act and those criteria Adam I'm just trying to keep us scoped and focused test. >> I I'd say it would be worth including in the history of the site within the the history of the evolution of that site, particularly the indigenous history section of that report, but not not to worry. We can continue discussion offline pertaining pertaining to the cultural daylighting practices >> perhaps. Yes. So, next question, please. >> Next question. Thank you. Um, is this property located within the McGill Graanby uh area of special identity? >> Uh, through you chair. Sorry, Adam. I that's not something I'm I would have the answer to at this moment. >> Other questions, Adam? [clears throat] >> Um, yes, of sorts. So, does this property have a neighborhood designation? Um if if I may uh through the chair um the planning designations are not actually a part of the provincial criteria. So um I believe that there are a series of zoning maps that are available online if you look if you wish to look up the specifics uh of properties and their planning context. Other questions? Adam. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. Uh, this property is located um within the you I'll leave this one for a comment rather than a question to the city staff. Thank you. >> Okay. Other questions of staff as we move forward. >> Seeing none, we have discussion and comment. Adam. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. Um, this property is located uh either in or immediately adjacent to the McGill Graanby Village uh area of special identity, which was first flagged as a unique downtown area uh in the early 1980s or late 1970s. There's a very high density of listed buildings within a threeb block radius. I think over 40 listed buildings within uh two or three city streets. um including a number of pre-1870 buildings, two reports of which we're seeing today and and two which I hope are forthcoming for for 60 uh sorry 47 to 97 Graanby Street. Um I just want to flag uh that there is significant community interest in the McGill Graanby Village and the listed properties and significant community concerns in um the potential loss of listings for this neighborhood which has had a stable heritage listing status for almost 50 years now. I'm hopeful that we'll see future Miguel Graanby properties designated and I'm grateful to see this designation report coming forward today and also grateful that staff took the time and the consultants took the time to include the 2s LGBTQ history. >> Thank you. Other comments or questions? >> Seeing none, I have a staff report with recommendations before us. Would anybody care to move those recommendations? I will. All those in favor, please. And that carries. Thank you very much. Moving on to PB 1.470 Gerard Street East across the street. Um, are there questions for staff? >> Seeing none, is there discussion amongst ourselves? >> Adam. >> Uh, thank you, Madam Chair. Uh, change to my earlier comments around the lost river in this neighborhood. This building danish late 1840s is one of the few buildings in downtown Toronto that was present when Moss Park Creek was still on the surface uh prior to its sewing in the in the 1850s. Um very grateful again to see a designation report coming forward for this site and and hopeful that we'll see future designation reports for listed properties in this area of the city of Toronto. It's very rich in uh in history. >> Thank you. Other comments or question or comments or discussion? Seeing none, I have a staff report with recommendations before me. Would anybody like to move the recommendations in the report? I'll kash. Thank you. All those in favor, please. And that carries. Moving on to PB 1.51 19 Dawn Ridge Drive. Again, no speakers. Um, do we have any questions for staff on this one? >> [clears throat] >> Mitch >> uh just that it's it's quite a large property if if you everyone's familiar with it. Um and there are several buildings. Am I to understand it's the church that's mostly um the focus here of our designation. >> Hello Adrian Gamble heritage planner here through you chair. Uh thanks Mitch for the question. Yes, the property is a quite a complex site, but for the purposes of this report, we are speaking only of the original church structure. >> Other questions? >> Seeing none, discussion amongst ourselves. >> Mitch, >> uh, being with the North York, uh, panel, uh, I can say on behalf of the whole panel, we're excited that this is coming forward. It is in in our zone. Also, um part of the North York panel is the little um area of Leid and the original settler John Lee after whom the area is uh named is buried there as well as some of his family members in a prominent spot. And the burial spots in themselves are worth a visit just uh the way they've been arranged and some of the ornate fence work around some of the tombstones. So, we're we're very happy about this and uh definitely support the designation. >> Other comments or discussion? >> Seeing none, I have a staff report with recommendations before me. Would anybody care to move those recommendations? Jeff. Thank you so much. All those in favor, please. And that carries. Moving on now to PB 1.6 1337 Queen Street um West. We have a st um a presentation available if people would like to hear it. Do we want to hear it? Yeah. Okay. So, we'll welcome Colin Hello. Sorry. Okay. Hello. Uh my name is Colin Pang. I'm a heritage planner with the city and I'm presenting uh PB 1.6 1337 Queen Street West demolition and new construction on a designated heritage property under part five section 42 of the Ontario Heritage Act. This report recommends that city council approve the demolition of an existing building on a non-contributing property located within the Parkdale Main Street uh HCD and improve the erection of a replacement building in accordance in connection with the city-led Parkdale hub project. Next slide. The subject property is an interior lot located between Dun Avenue and Cohen Cowen Avenue on the south side of Queen Street West City is undertaking the revitalization and expansion of the Park Dell hub which is a strategic city building initiative that aims to revitalize and expand upon an existing cluster of city-owned facilities and community services including the Toronto Public Library, Parkdale Branch and the Mazerich uh Co Cowan Community Recreation center. It consists of several properties which will provide new affordable rental housing, improved community facilities, and modernized public spaces. The project consists of three blocks, center, west, and east. Next slide. The property currently contains an existing one-story building and it's identifi identified as a non-contributing property within the HCD plan. Next slide. The city is seeking heritage approval for the demolition of the existing building and the construction of a proposed 16story mixeduse building with a fourstory podium building. Uh the property is part of the west block of the Parkdale Hub project which will accommodate housing purpose-built affordable housing and non-residential uses on the ground floor. A heritage permit for the project was previously approved on June 24th and 25th of this year by city council. The current proposal is largely the same as previous approval, but a change has been made to the height of the podium building at this time, which has triggered the need for a new heritage permit um as it no longer complies with the HCD policies. Therefore, a new um approval under section 42 of the OA is required. The site plan for the proposal is shown on this slide on uh on this slide and uh a link to the previous approval can be found in the staff report should you wish to look into the details of that. Next slide. So the next few slides will show the new street wall height of the new podium which has been increased by 1.2 meters and it's shown in red. It no longer matches the height of the adjacent contributing building at 1347 Queen Street West and it does not include the 5 meter stepback which is required by the Parkdale HCD plan for any parts of the new building which are taller than the adjacent contributing building. So one of the objectives as noted in the staff report is to conserve the historic main street character of the district including its consistent street wall scale and fine grain built form. There is however no continuous or consistent street wall along this part of the south side of Queen Street West. Therefore, although it doesn't strictly comply with the policies of the HCD plan, the proposed modest increase in the height of 1.2 meters from the previous approved scheme for the podium building would not harm the character or appearance of the district and would not be contrary to the objectives of the HCD plan. Uh therefore staff have no concern with the lack of a step back over the top of the new podium building in this location. Next slide. The slide shows the east elevation of the new podium and tower building. The stepbacks and the design of the new tower above the podium building will remain unchanged. Again these dimensions along with the uh previously approved proposal can be found uh in the link in the report. Next slide. And these are some of the renderings just showing the approved scheme on top and the revised scheme showing the street wall height increase on the bottom. So staff are of the opinion that the proposed revisions to the building mass remains compatible with the adjacent contributing properties and continues to achieve the intent and objectives of the HCD. Therefore, we recommend approval of the H of the heritage permit application. And uh that is all. Yeah. >> Thank you very much. Do we have questions for staff? >> Jeff? >> Well, this um seems like a no-brainer this this um I'm just surprised that um uh required a heritage permit. I guess it obviously it's because it's in an ACD, but I presume the policies in this particular ACD were fairly restrictive um in requiring even properties that do not currently contain heritage listed or or protected properties that would be have to comply with the heritage district to a significant you know fairly significant constraints on there. Anyway, it seems like it's um is this is this frequent that this happens with an ECD? Um I don't recall this of a similar nature. >> You mean you've had twice a onetory retail actually being you know, by something that conforms with an ACV plan as a new construction. It seems like it's a very innovative and progressive um idea actually. >> Yeah. Well, there's a few answers to that. This is the second time we've come to you. You did review an original project which generally did the same thing. The reason why we're coming back to report, which seems minor, but we think it's really fundamental is that um the guidelines policies and guidelines indicate that you have to take into consideration the prevailing street wall >> and um and you know sets certain requirements for that and we are okay with the additional height here because there is no prevailing street wall in this particular block. There are in most of the other blocks. Um so we felt it was really important to go on record. This is not a precedent saying this approach would be okay everywhere being a little taller than we had required. Um so it's a minor point but an important one just to be really clear about how we expect the base to fit into the context. >> Yeah. It's just an example of how the HC having an HCD benefits the the street basically the future of the street >> benefits the street and allows for you wouldn't have had this >> this street wall maintained you would have had >> you know who knows what you have just towers I guess >> correct Mitch you've got a question >> yeah um to staff so traditionally there's the shop house at ground level and then usually two or second floor or maybe a third floor with apartments. So, is that's going to be replicated? Will the second, third, and fourth floors in this case now be uh rental apartments above the shops? >> Um currently, uh working through the chair through working with our planning colleagues that is still to be determined I believe uh through the site plan stage. So, that is something that um our colleagues in community planning will be looking to um finalize. >> Thanks. Other questions? Adam. >> Thank you, Madam Chair, and um thank you to Toronto staff for this report. Um I'll start with the question pertinent to the Queen Street elevation and the neighboring heritage property. Uh for those of you familiar with this site, um the line of sight across 1337 Queen to 1347 Queen, which the 1347 Queen Tequa Week's building, later known as the Sovereign Apartments, um there is a very large ghost sign on the neighboring heritage building, which is a contributing heritage building. The ghost sign is for two businesses. The first is Sovereign Perfumes. Sovereign Perfumes was established in Parkdale in the early 20th century. It became the largest all Canadian-owned perfume company uh in Canadian history. Uh later opening a factory on Brock Avenue and then another ghost sign for Coca-Cola. But these ghost signs are well-known community landmarks and a well-loved feature on this section of Queen Street. And this new design which brings forward the building right up to the adjacent property uh line in the wall without the 5 m set back is now covering up ghost sign. Are there plans to fully document that ghost sign um before uh it's lost um with this building covering it up >> uh through the chair. Uh ghost signs are not referenced within the HCD plan. So, it wasn't something that was taken into consideration in responding to the application. Um, however, we can certainly um include uh a documentation requirement uh or aspect to the project. So, that's that's fair enough. >> Other questions? >> Thank you. U madam chair I may uh introduce a motion requesting that documentation element of the adjacent ghost sign if that's >> sorry Adam you do that at discussion point and you may or you are because you've just had an answer city staff saying that they're going to do it. Do you need further than than than that? >> I I'd like to to have a motion regardless to include documentation >> then please draft it and send it to clerks. >> I'll draft it right now. Thank you so much. >> Thank you. Um and and just to be clear through the chair, uh motion should uh request something to happen because we we can ask for it to be done, but it isn't actually um because the development isn't actually happening on that parcel. Um I I don't see no reason why the owner uh why the applicant wouldn't comply. Um but it cannot form a part of any um decision- making here. Are there other questions, Adam? >> Uh, thank you, Madam Chair. Do we have um renderings or um site plans indicating the rear elevation where there is a proposal to reconnect a pedestrian walkway between Nazer Park and the subject site? the uh illustrate the site plan drawings that we see in the does in the report before us um still indicates the presence of a chain link fence and does not indicate the reconnection of that pedestrian walkway but the written portion does indicate it will be reconnected through a walkway. So there's some discrepancy. Is there >> uh through the chair? I believe as I suggested before, committee planning is still looking at the site plan stage at this point. So any sort of refinements or revisions to the rest of the site, which we did not review um is is uh subject to change at this point, I believe. >> Other questions? Adam. Thank you, Madam Chair. Um, if Heritage Planning could clarify who their um who in community planning has carriage of this file, it would be greatly appreciated. The signs uh on the subject site are so heavily vandalized, you cannot see which planner has been assigned to this file. Um, and I I'm happy to follow up regarding that walkway and refinement related concerns, uh, including preservation of public art elements that are on the site today, including Peter Dicos sculptures of native trees, uh, on the adjacent 220 Cowan Avenue site. But I just want to flag if you are actually there in person looking for the contact information for community planning, it's so graffitied over you can't read it. uh if it uh through the chair if it's not available on the application information center uh we can certainly send that to you offline. >> Thank thank you um Mary. >> Other questions? Seeing none, we are going to take a beat as we wait for the wording of the motion because I think we'll hold our discussion until then. Um couple of things. So, one, we'll get our schedule for next year hopefully in early December, but um as was clarified earlier, so much is tied to the council schedule. So, hold tight. The second is um communications. Um in the email that we received from clerks, they sort of highlighted that communications are being treated differently. They're all posted online, so we won't get a separate email indicating and having them in in the text. But much like all of our other materials, they are posted and easily accessible. So just as a as a flag if anybody was looking for those. And now we'll just wait. Cue the elevator music for a moment or two. >> I'm sorry I didn't understand your last point. >> Yes. Uh, the draft motion has been sent for review. >> Thank you. Hold tight. Adam, clerks have it. They're just, you know, running it through the um put, you know, putting the finesse on it to make it into a motion. So, hold tight still. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. That ghost line really is such a remarkable part of Parkville's history, too, with Sovereign Perfumes originating in in the neighboring building and rises to be Canada's largest all Canadian-owned perfume company. Really quite a remarkable history. Oh, can folks still hear me? >> Yeah, but we're going to need to be >> I appear to be frozen. >> No, we can hear you. Can't see you, but we're going to need to be able to see you moving forward for voting. >> Yeah. Can you see me now? >> Yep. >> Fabulous. Sorry, it froze on my end. I was worried that everything had frozen. No, we're we're we're still trucking along. >> Thank you. Um, also, uh, for for those interested, there was a recent, Madam Chair, there was a recent OLT decision around pre-1870s, uh, workingclass vernacular architecture, uh, which identified that in the city of Toronto, only 2% of all the buildings on the Heritage Register predated 1870 and that it was an underrepresented aspect on our heritage register. and a um and that working-class vernacular architecture was also underrepresented. And if anyone's interested in finding out more about that decision, it's for 15 Elm Street. And I I'm very thankful and grateful for all the city staff and those that put time and resources into that Ontario land tribunal case. >> Thank >> and it's wonderful to see that designation upheld. >> Thanks, Adam. Adam, the motion was just sent back to you, so have a look, please. Yes, thank you. >> It's all good, Adam. >> Yes. Do we we need do we need to clarify the specific location of the ghost sign or is that self-evident within the motion? >> It was determined to be self-evident within the mo in the motion. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. >> We can proceed then. >> Marvelous. Let's pull that up. Uh so the motion before us moved by Adam is that to request the senior manager Heritage Planning Urban Design City Planning to document the ghost sign for Sovereign Perfumes and Coca-Cola prior to the construction of the new building at 13371339 Queen Street West and considered for commemoration within the interpretation plan. So, Adam has sort of spoken to the reasons why. Do you have anything further to add, Adam? >> Um, yes. Thank Thank you, Madam Chair. I I want to add that the Parkdale Main Street uh heritage conservation district is a commercial Main Street heritage conservation district. And these ghost signs are a integral part of our advertising history within the city of Toronto. And furthermore, this specific sign has been highly visible to the Parkdale neighborhood for over 100 years at this point in time. It's been a landmark on the section of Queen Street. Many people recognize the sign. Many people enjoy the sign and for it now to be covered up 100 years later uh after it was painted. Um I think it definitely needs to be documented and definitely should be commemorated within the within the future project. And also it's um a Canadian company uh especially the sovereign perfumes a Canadian company one of the largest if not the largest Canadian perfume company in our history. >> Any uh questions for Adam or discussion? Mitch? >> Yeah, I'm a fan of ghost signs we see in entertainment district and Leslieville all around town. Um I noticed that some of those Parkdale signs are heavily graffitied as you say that seems to be a zone. not just the application sign but also your um 19th century ghost signs to the point where some of the wording is covered up. So I don't know what would happen going forward. I mean restoration of the ghost signs because it decays and degrades right it's painted on brick. >> It's a fair question. Um right now though I think a good first step is the documentation um and then um ability to move forward. Adam. >> Uh, thank you, Madam Chair. There is some minor graffiti around the edges. That being said, um, there's kind of twofold that allowed for the protection of this ghost sign over the past few decades. One is that there is a freestanding billboard uh, for a decade in front of it, which regardless, this sign was still visible for over a hundred years uh, prior to the erection of that temporary freestanding billboard. And it's entirely inaccessible um, unless you're on a a ladder. Um it's two to three stories up in height and there's no adjacent building to it so it's remained visible. >> So moving back to the amended amendment before us are there any is there further discussion on this >> Mitch chair um housekeeping um I think wording in the motion it should be signs rather than sign because there's a reference to two signs. >> Thank you yes for that clarification. Thank you. >> Could we make that amendment, please? Thank you, Madam Chair. >> The change has been made. Um, >> thank you. >> Are there further points of discussion? >> Seeing none, Adam has moved this amendment. All those in favor of the amendment, please raise your hand. And that carries. Fantastic. Moving back into discussion of the um recommendations as as amendment. So the item as amended. Is there any further discussion on it? Seeing none, I have a staff report. Yes, Adam. >> Oh, thank you, Madam Chair. Um I will I will follow up with Heritage Planning and and city planning staff regarding that walkway as well. And I appreciate the clarification that this is still in the works and do want to just reiterate that there are some discrepancies with the uh mention of a pedestrian connection to the adjacent public park and adjacent heritage buildings at the Mazerich Community Center and and this subject site and how uh the illustrations still show the presence of a chain link fence in the new design. >> Okay, thank you. Other points of Yes, Mitch. Yeah, it's great that this re revitalization is happening in this particular strip of uh Queen Street West partail. It's just um and I know staff are great at what they're doing, so I defer often to uh their expertise, but I'm just a little concerned about um moving the goalpost so to speak with uh the HCD Parkell language. Uh it was agreed upon three floors stories and now four. So, I'm just I'm not a pessimist, but I'm just worried maybe developer will see now that they can push it maybe in the next project to five. So, that the language is I know it's not sac sacrosanked, but I'm just a little concerned that the language in the HCD for Parkdale um is being tampered with. It's just my comment. >> No, I think not an unfair one. I'll return to one of the comments that Jeff made earlier about how um with contributing and non-contributing and what's in place in terms of the consideration of new construction that it's quite robust and that my sense is that you take things on a project by project basis. So I was satisfied when staff you said this doesn't create a precedent and that each building has to be understood in and of its own right within the context of this HCD. it is a newer one. So there is a lot more guidelines within this HCD um in terms of the protection of you know this this commercial main street and and the area. So I I take your concern but I'm going to remain very optimistic that as a on a case-byase basis we have a robust HCD with really strong guidelines in place to help guide and manage change going forward. >> Um other points of discussion Seeing none, I have a staff report as amended before. Would anybody like to move that recommend the recommendations? Okay, Mitch. Thank you very much. All those in favor, please. That is done. Motion carries. And that concludes our business today. I will see. >> Madam Chair, >> yes. Sorry, Paul. Uh I I apologize for breaking in at the last minute and uh I should have I should have remembered this at the beginning of the meeting and I didn't or I would have said something then. But I just um wanted to uh uh recognize that October 30th uh Denise Harris passed away. Uh she was the past president of the Atobbico Historical Society. She was a former chair of the Atobbo New York uh community preservation panel. um she um I can't think of anyone who has had more impact on um preserving and documenting history in a Tobico. If you look at the EHS website, there's just a phenomenal number of articles and and uh um pages that that she authored and she was an amazing teacher to members of of the Atobico panel uh over the years as well. So, um, just just want to remember her and, um, that that's all I wanted to say. >> No, thank you, Paul. A somber note to end our meeting, but one where her legacy in the work that she does is is is worthy of remembrance. Thank you. That concludes our business today. We'll see everybody in a couple of weeks. The meeting is adjourned.