Townhall Tracker

Board Advances Multiple Heritage Designations - 16 Nov 26

Toronto · AI-assisted summary by Claude and Parth · Published

Toronto Preservation Board Advances Heritage Protections

The Toronto Preservation Board advanced heritage protections for properties at 8 Arnold Avenue, 106 Beverly Street, 66 and 70 Gerrard Street East, and 119 Dawn Ridge Drive. It also approved an amended heritage permit for a Parkdale development at 1337–1339 Queen Street West, allowing a taller podium and no five-metre upper-level stepback. The board required historic "ghost signs" that will be covered by construction to be documented and considered for commemoration.

Topics Discussed

Bill 23 and Heritage-Protection Deadlines

Staff told the board that the city is working under the statutory deadlines created by Ontario's Bill 23, which can remove properties from the municipal heritage register if they are not designated within prescribed timelines.

Staff said work on properties from the 1870s was "largely wrapping up." A January report is expected to outline a broader strategy for properties from the pre-1870s and post-1960s periods.

Board member Jeff asked how the city would address properties facing the loss of their listed status: "Because we're losing the listing status and only a couple of months. So I'm just wondering what the plan here is?"

Heritage Designations

The board advanced designations for several properties:

  • 8 Arnold Avenue: Staff recommended an emergency designation after the owner submitted a demolition application for the 1870s Mount Dennis residence. Staff said the building "maintains its integrity," while also identifying concerns about its condition. The board carried the recommendation.
  • 106 Beverly Street: The board unanimously approved a Notice of Intention to Designate the property, including the Estston and Georgina Houses. Heritage planner Adrien Gamble said architect Eden Smith's alterations between 1909 and 1914 included "the veranda, the rear wing, interior modifications, and the Osler wing."
  • 66 Gerrard Street East: The board advanced designation of the site, which includes three attached row houses dating to approximately 1855 and a 1910 addition. Member Adam noted the property's 2SLGBTQ+ history and asked whether Heritage Planning has "a cultural daylighting policy" for properties on or beside lost rivers. The property sits above buried Moss Park Creek.
  • 70 Gerrard Street East: The board advanced designation of the late-1840s building. Adam said it was "one of the few buildings in downtown Toronto that was present when Moss Park Creek was still on the surface."
  • 119 Dawn Ridge Drive: The board unanimously advanced designation of the original church building. The associated cemetery includes the graves of early settler John Lee and family members.

Parkdale Development and Heritage Permit

The board approved an amended heritage permit for a development at approximately 1337–1339 Queen Street West in the Parkdale Main Street Heritage Conservation District.

The project would replace a one-storey commercial building with a 16-storey mixed-use building with a four-storey podium. It forms part of the Parkdale Hub, a city initiative that includes affordable rental housing, improved community facilities and modernized public spaces, including the Toronto Public Library's Parkdale branch and the Masaryk-Cowan Community Recreation Centre. Heritage planner Colin Pang described the project as a plan to "revitalize and expand upon an existing cluster of city-owned facilities and community services."

The amended design raises the podium by 1.2 metres and removes the usual five-metre upper-level stepback beside 1347 Queen Street West. Staff acknowledged that the change does not strictly comply with the Heritage Conservation District plan but said it "would not harm the character or appearance of the district."

Member Mitch questioned the change from three storeys to four and whether it could encourage future requests for additional height. The board also sought further information about rental-unit tenure, a proposed pedestrian connection to Nazer Park and the protection of nearby public art.

Queen Street "Ghost Signs"

The approved development will cover historic Coca-Cola and Sovereign Perfumes advertisements on the wall of the adjacent Sovereign Apartments because the new building will be constructed without the five-metre setback.

Adam described the signs as "an integral part of our advertising history within the city of Toronto" and said the specific sign had been visible in the Parkdale neighbourhood for more than 100 years. He called it "a landmark on the section of Queen Street" that many residents recognize and enjoy.

The board amended the motion to require Heritage Planning staff to photograph and document the signs before construction and consider commemorating them through the building's heritage interpretation plan.

Heritage Conservation District Policy and Memorial

The board carried amended staff recommendations concerning heritage-conservation guidelines for a commercial main street. Applications will be assessed individually rather than treated as establishing an automatic precedent.

Before adjournment, the board recognized Denise Harris, the former president of the Etobicoke Historical Society and a former chair of the Etobicoke York Community Preservation Panel. Member Paul Ainslie said, "I can't think of anyone who has had more impact on preserving and documenting history in Etobicoke."

Motions

  • 8 Arnold Avenue — Notice of Intention to Designate: Passed.
  • 106 Beverly Street — Notice of Intention to Designate: Passed unanimously.
  • 66 Gerrard Street East — Notice of Intention to Designate: Advanced/carried.
  • 70 Gerrard Street East — Notice of Intention to Designate: Advanced/carried.
  • 119 Dawn Ridge Drive — Notice of Intention to Designate: Passed unanimously.
  • 1337–1339 Queen Street West — Amended heritage permit: Passed, allowing the revised podium height and stepback treatment.
  • 1337–1339 Queen Street West — Documentation of ghost signs: Amended motion passed, requiring the signs to be documented and considered for commemoration.
  • Commercial main street Heritage Conservation District staff report: Amended recommendations carried.
  • Parkdale pedestrian connection, rental housing details and public-art protection: Referred for site-plan review or further staff follow-up; no final decision was recorded.

Attendees

The transcript identifies the following board members or participants:

  • Jeff
  • Adam
  • Mitch
  • Paul Ainslie

Staff and presenters identified in the meeting included:

  • Adrien Gamble, heritage planner
  • Colin Pang, heritage planner
  • Representatives of the Toronto East York Community Preservation Panel

A complete official attendance list was not provided in the meeting material.

Watch the source meeting · Read transcript