← Back to summary

Full Transcript

Council Opposes Provincial Midtown Zoning Orders - 18 Nov 26

Oakville · November 19, 2026

Good evening, [clears throat] ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to our special meeting of town council for Wednesday, November 18th, 2026. Madam Clerk, do we have any regrets this evening? >> Thank you, Mayor Noelle. We have regrets from Councillor Chisholm. >> Okay, thank you. Members of council, do you have any declarations of pecuniary interest to report? Seeing none, we do not have any consent items. We do not have any confidential consent items. We have one discussion item, 5.1. It's the Midtown update and a potential resolution after that's concluded. I do want to point out though before we get into the meeting, I just want to acknowledge and recognize that newly appointed regional chair and Melvilles in the audience today. Welcome, Anne. Thanks for being here this evening. [applause] Okay, we're going staff, do you have a do you wish to comment on tonight's report or we go right into delegations? >> Mayor Noelle, I think the report is pretty self-explanatory and the motion is as well, so we had no further comments. >> Okay, thank you. So everybody is aware of the fact that tonight we are discussing or we will be discussing a motion with respect to the disposition of the Minister's zoning orders and our desire to proceed with OPA 70. So that's setting the context for the evening. What I'm going to do is we have [snorts] we have two items on the agenda. One is the update itself and what I'll do is I will what are the delegations registered for, 5.1 or 5.2? Okay, there are no delegations registered for 5.1. It's simply an update. So I'm going to look for a motion to receive the report entitled Midtown Update. Thank you, Morgan. Sorry, Councillor Elliott and Councillor Lapworth. All in favor? That is received. So we're moving on to 5.2. I'm going to call for delegations this time. Madam Clerk, do we have a registered delegation? >> Thank you, Mayor Noelle. We have James Goodfellow from We Love Oakville. Please proceed with your delegation. >> By >> while Mr. Goodfellow is coming to the podium, we typically have a procedural bylaw that requires registration to delegate prior to noon the day of council meetings. If there's somebody in the audience, and it looks like there's a whole whack of people behind Jim, but if there's somebody that has something to add that was not presented during the Midtown during We Love Oakville's presentation, we will contemplate We'll consider waving the rules and allowing that to happen. But listen carefully to this presentation. Maybe they'll cover it all. So with that, Mr. Goodfellow. >> Okay, and I'm going to introduce George. >> Okay. Well done. >> Good evening. Thank you very much for the opportunity. I'd like to start by introducing ourselves. My name is George Niblock, and we are We Love Oakville. We're a grassroots community group with a membership of over 8,000 people, residents across Oakville. Tonight, we have the support of numerous residents' associations and community groups standing with me and in the council chamber and in Overflow Atrium, including Joshua Creek Residents Association, Trafalgar Chartwell Residents Association, Oakville Lakeside Residents Association, Chartwell Maple Grove Residents Association, West River Residents Association, Coronation Park Residents Association, Brontë Village Residents Association, Clearview Residents Association, West Curve Village Residents Association, as well as the support of other community groups, including Oakville Green and the OCA. In fact, there were no community groups that we reached out to that have declined to support this initiative. This support is truly town-wide. We look forward to support from our MPP Steven Crawford, who has worked with us in the past, and he We hope he is here and watching this evening. We'll be insisting that he join Team Oakville in this united effort to return Oakville planning matters to Oakville. But before handing over to my WLO co-chair Jim Goodfellow, I'd like to offer my congratulations to the mayor and council on your election and for putting this critical matter at the top of your agenda. We understand from speaking to many of you that Midtown Oakville was the number one issue you heard from residents at doors as you knocked in every single ward across town. Through your leadership and as Team Oakville, we must now deliver a clear message to Queen's Park. Thank you very much and Jim Goodfellow. >> Thank you. Let me also echo George's comment about congratulating you on your decision for service to the town and and also thank the members who decided not to run and for all of their contributions. So thank you all. Okay, what I'm going to do tonight is we've sent a letter to you outlining for the benefit of the audience and I'm going to quickly summarize the letter and and what we're all about. Let me just also emphasize here as we start the fact of this is a team effort. These folks all been involved in it and the other part is our team is all the people who are here tonight. So this is a team effort. So, Mayor Noelle and members of council: [snorts] on behalf of We Love Oakville and the undersigned residents' associations that George referred to, we are writing to express our strong support for Mayor Noelle's motion calling on the province to: number one, revoke the four Midtown transit-oriented (TOCs) MZOs;, approve Oakville's plan, OPA 70; and three, revoke council's confidential distinction direction relating to the TOC lands. Okay? Um So, our ask is simple. Our ask is for council to stand up together and support this motion. That's the ask. Let me tell you a little bit about our rationale for why we got here. Now, we could spend forever talking about our complaints on the TOC. So, we won't have but here's trying the succinct parts of what why we are First part We want to be clear that we love Oakville supports responsible growth. We support increased housing supply. We support inclusionary zoning, streamlining permitting streamlining the permitting process, and transit-oriented housing for a flexible for a livable Midtown Oakville. We supported OPA 70 and the council's approved and the council approval of the 14-tower development at 420 South Service Road East. We strongly believe that growth must be guided by comprehensive planning, not planned on an application by application basis. Um We strongly support the necessary infrastructure and shaped through meaningful public consultation. The four MZOs imposed by the province bypassed Oakville's planning process. They overrode the work of directed by council. They disregarded considerable town and community engagement uh and they ignored the need for a comprehensive plan for Midtown. They have to go. The province's subsequent commitment to reduce the building heights from 56 to 38 stories satisfies one objective, which is NAV Canada's objections. But it does not resolve the fundamental issues of extreme density, necessary infrastructure, massive transportation and gridlock issues some of us experienced trying to get here tonight. Gridlock, community amenities and the proper alignment of the TOC development with Oakville's plan for the future. Oakville's plan for Midtown, OPA 70 is a comprehensive plan that Oakville needs. It meets all provincial requirements. Council's approval of 420 South Service Road East demonstrates one other thing. It demonstrates that substantial growth can be accomplished within Oakville's plan. I think the plan can work. We see no justification for withdrawing the withholding the approval of Oakville 's plan for Midtown, namely OPA 70 which has been sitting somewhere in Queen's Park for since February 25. Um OPA 70 must be approved by the province now without modification. Lost my conclusion. We must We must also strongly support we Oakville also strongly supports your third part of your resolution for council to revoke the March 23-26 confidential direction for Midtown. We recognize that there's a need for in-camera sessions, but decisions affecting the future of Midtown must be transparent and accountable to the residents. So we support that part of your motion. So in closing, and I want to be positive here, which is difficult because I'm a Leafs fan. So here's the positive conclusion. We commend you, Mayor Noelle, for your leadership in bringing this motion forward with such urgency. And we ask every member of council to support all three parts of your resolution. We also recognize the high-level commitment to Midtown by candidates and residents through the municipal elections. We love Oakville and the undersigned and I think all the people in this room um equivocally and wholeheartedly support this motion. And furthermore, what what we see here today, uh Mayor Noelle, is building what George called Team Oakville. It has to start with you folks. You guys got to be all on the same page. I think this and that's what we're looking for. We're looking to see are you all on the same page. The second part is then how to reach out. We hope this shows you that we're anxious to work with you in doing whatever the organizations that are represented here and the people in the room and in the atrium that are here. We're here for one reason to to be part of that team. And together, if we pull all pull together, we can course correct this ship and achieve a very positive outcome. But I'm not so sure about the Leafs. Thank you very much. >> Thank you Mr. Goodfellow. [applause] I like to canvass the audience to see if there's anybody who would like uh to speak in addition to our friends from We Love Oakville or did he speak for everybody in this room. Okay, seeing none, I going to uh advise you that I'm passing the chair to Councillor Adams because I'm going to be proposing the motion. So Councillor Adams, you have the chair. >> Thanks very much, Mayor Noll. I'm going to read out the resolving clause of the motion and then I'll give it out to you and the seconder to speak as well as other members of council if if so wished. The motion has a whole bunch of whereases, but the clause that matters is: Now, therefore, be it resolved: one That council requests the Minister of Infrastructure revoke zoning order 01-2026, 02-2026, 03-2026, and 04-2026 for the TOC lands; two That council requests that the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing approve OPA 70 as adopted by council without delay and without modifications to conform OPA 70 to the MZOs; and three That the confidential direction approved by council on March 23, 2026, related to the TOC lands be revoked. Mayor Noll, as the mover, do you have some comments that you'd like to provide? >> I just happen to, yes. So thank you members of council and thank you to everybody who came out tonight. And I understand that not only do we have a full council chamber, but we have 80 to 85 people in the atrium. So well done. Thank you for the quick the quick return on the on attendance. So tonight's a very important moment for the new council and for the people of Oakville. During the municipal election, I spent a great deal of time knocking on doors, participating in debates, attending community meetings, and speaking to residents across our town as did everybody else except those who got acclaimed. They will remain nameless. And while many important issues were raised, one issue stood above all others. The minister the Midtown Oakville and sorry, Midtown Oakville and the province's decision to impose minister zoning orders therein. Without question, it was the number one issue that I heard during the election and talking to some of my colleagues, I think they were in the same boat. People were frustrated. They were concerned about the scale of development, the impact on traffic, infrastructure and surrounding neighborhoods and the province's decision to override the planning work undertaken by the town. But perhaps most importantly, they were upset that decisions of this magnitude were being made without respecting the voices of residents and the decisions of their elected council. And one thing became very clear. People are not actually opposed to growth, but they want growth done properly. They understand that Midtown, with its proximity to the GO station, is an appropriate place for responsible development. But they expect that growth to be thoroughly planned and supported by the infrastructure necessary to make it work. That's precisely what Oakville set out to achieve through official plan amendment number 70. OPA 70 was the product of extensive professional planning, technical analysis and public consultation and debate around this council table. It represents a vision for Midtown that accommodates significant growth while balancing the needs of the existing community. And yet, despite all that work, OPA 70 remains unapproved by the province and as Jim says, floating somewhere around Queen's Park somewhere. Instead, we were presented with four minister zoning orders that fundamentally changed the planning framework for these lands. The province has since suggested reducing building heights, but reducing heights while maintaining the same density doesn't resolve the underlying concerns that we have. We also have concerns raised by NAV CANADA about potential impacts on aviation operations, demonstrating why comprehensive planning is so important. We need more than adjustments to a plan imposed on us. We need the province to respect the plan that Oakville delivered. Throughout the election, I made a clear commitment to the people of Oakville. If elected mayor, I would bring this matter back before council and seek united position, calling on the province to revoke revoke the forums at O's and approve OPA 70. During on Monday night during my inaugural address, I repeated that commitment and that's why we're here tonight. I want to acknowledge the residents and community organizations, particularly We Love Oakville and all of the residents that stand behind them. Their countless delegations, careful research, and tireless advocacy have helped keep these issues at the forefront. Now this motion is not about stopping growth or refusing to work with the province, far from it. We recognize the importance of housing and transit-oriented development. We want to be constructive partners in achieving those goals, but partnership must be a two-way street. Tonight we're asking the province to revoke Ford's MZOs, approve OPA 70 as adopted by Council, and allow us to move forward with a clear and consistent planning direction. Now I recognize that passing this motion itself will not revoke the MZOs. That authority still rests with the province. But what we can do tonight is make Oakville's position unmistakably clear. The people of Oakville spoke during the election. They spoke through the delegations, their letters, and their advocacy, and by your attendance here tonight. And tonight, through their elected representatives, they have an opportunity to speak with one voice. I hope every member of Council will join me in sending a strong, united, respectful message to Queen's Park and for all of us to join Team Oakville. As I said Monday night, let it be heard through the halls of Queen's Park and the streets of Oakville and across Ontario. Let Oakville plan Oakville. Thank you. >> Thank you very much. Councillor Hazelton, do you have any comments as a seconder? >> It's pretty hard to beat that one. Um thanks very much uh Chair Adams. Um I want to begin by saying thank you to all of the we love Oakville and every single one of you that got late notice and arrived um and have reinforced how important this is to you um and the numerous emails I got saying we're watching online, but we just couldn't get there. So thank you for showing that we're all engaged in trying to do the right thing. I also want to thank Mayor Noll um for recognizing the importance of addressing Midtown and moving so quickly to bring this matter forward and including us in drafting the motion. I can't thank you enough, Jeff. You have our full support. Midtown has the potential to become an important part of Oakville's future, but that future must be shaped by what the area can realistically support. We have approximately 65 hectares of developable land, three major arterial roads squashing people in, an existing GO station that is incredibly busy with significant transportation and infrastructure challenges. We cannot ignore these realities simply because there's a desire to accommodate more and more housing. That is why the work behind OPA 70 is so important to reflect on. It really was the result of thoughtful planning, economic and technical expertise, market analysis, and considerable public input and solutions. We looked at the potential development, the employment opportunities, the mix of housing needs, community benefits, and importantly, how landowners could be an a good part of making this a complete community. One of the important lessons that I think we should all have taken away through one of the experts' reports is that putting more people into an area does not change its physical constraints, nor does it necessarily make housing more attractive. In fact, it doesn't make it attractive. Good planning is about optimizing land, not maximizing density. It means getting that balance right, green space, places for people to play, employment, services, amenities. It means creating a community people really want to live there. And so that's what OPA 70 does. We weren't simply trying to plan for housing units. We understand we have to hit our housing targets. We were planning and have a plan that will allow a community to emerge where people can live and work and raise families and put down roots, all of the things all of you chose Oakville for. And so that brings me to why I am pleased to second this motion. We're asking the province to revoke those four MZOs. We cannot achieve the potential of Midtown with two competing planning frameworks determining Midtown's future. We need one vision, one plan. That plan is OPA 70, which also enables the province to respect the serious safety concerns raised by Metrolinx. Second, we're asking that province to approve OPA 70 without further delay or modification. We've done the hard work. Use it. Borrow our homework. It's good work. We've engaged the residents. We've completed the analysis, and it is a bold, comprehensive plan. And further delays jeopardize the potential for all stakeholders in Midtown. And finally, we're asking Council to rescind its earlier direction so we can move forward with one clear, consistent position. Achieving a unanimous direction tonight will send a positive message to our staff and to our community, clarity and confidence to move forward as Team Oakville. To my colleagues, we came together unanimously when we adopted OPA 70. And I know that with this new Council and with your support, we can make a strong case for Midtown and for Oakville. I did a little research, and the provincial planning statement says the following. Above all, Ontario will continue to be a great place to live, work, and visit where all Ontarians enjoy a high standard of living and an exceptional quality of life, unquote. I think we all agree with that vision. It's exactly what we want in Oakville and in Midtown. And so do the province, if you're listening. We can help deliver that vision when you return planning responsibility to Oakville and approve OPA 70 as adopted. We don't have to choose between provincial housing and transit objectives and a community that's responsibly planned. We know we can do both. I'm often asked why this matters so much to me. Why are you giving this so much time? And my family's been very generous about that. Look around at the great place we have the good fortune to call home. Think about our children and our grandchildren. They will inherit the decisions we make and that we enable the province to make and we call to the province to help us move this OPA forward. We owe that generation more than a housing count or a cluster of towers with a patch or two of grass. We owe them a community with the quality of life we are known for, a vibrant livable community where residents thrive, not just survive. And I know you're not surviving Trafalgar traffic. I promise we're working on it. Let's stand together tonight. In the weeks ahead, let's stand united. >> Councilor, I'm just mindful of our procedural bylaw in the five minutes. Are you just about finished? >> I am, Councilor. Um so let's stand together tonight and in the weeks ahead, united as a council and residents to make the case to the premier, to his ministers, to our our minister in Oakville that we are committed to achieving a new community in Midtown and we need them to let Oakville plan Oakville. One Midtown, one vision, one plan. I hope I have unanimous support tonight and I'm calling for a recorded vote. >> Thank you, Councilor Elliot. >> I want to speak in favor of this motion. Um you know, at the doors over the last few months um I heard residents consistently concerned about overdevelopment. It wasn't no development, it was overdevelopment. And I heard that residents uh want somewhere close by where their families can up. Um while others talked about wanting to to downsize, but being able to uh stay in in the area where they love where their friends are and where their services are. And they're demanding responsible smart development. They're not saying no development. And their frustrations certainly resulted in the composition of the current council here today. You know, we've heard from the RA's tonight and I just want to say a personal note to to thank the mayor for for making this the number one priority uh of this session. Um you know, a couple days after the election he was already engaging with us in terms of uh wanting to bring this motion uh forward. And I certainly want to say thank you to uh counselors uh Jen Hasslethales and and Councilor Gittings for the work over the last couple years on this issue. In fact, we've been dealing with this issue for so long that two years ago I was on the other side of the dais and I worry if we continue this I might be old in the parking lot the next two years. So it'd be nice to get this done sooner rather than later. And I really want to thank W WLO WeLoveOakville. They've been fantastic in in gathering the support of all the residents associations across uh across the town. And again, the the town is not against development. Just look at the South Service Road project uh that that was approved. You know, you you've got lots of units on lots of land versus you know, immense density with with no parkland. It just it doesn't make sense. We all understand the need uh and support the need to build homes. There's there's no question about that. We can even meet the provincial goals for for housing and we want to work with the province. Uh but something can look good and sensible on on paper in isolation, but when you put it in the real context of of the neighborhood and the people who live live there it just it doesn't hold up. There I could speak for hours on this, but you know, the orders don't take into consideration the other developments next to these sites. You know, we already have another development in front of the books that has even greater density uh that's being proposed here. I also have grave concerns uh that this could eventually overextend uh both the city's resources and and its finances. And I just want to say I support this. This is not about the province. It's we want to work with the province, but within the parameters of our our official plan that's been uh developed over the years. So I will definitely be supporting this motion. >> Thank you very much. Are there any other speakers? I see none. Then I'll call a recorded vote. If the clerk could name each member and uh for the public and for our new members, a clear yes or no is required. >> Thank you Chair Adams. >> Yes. >> Counselor McNiece. >> Yes. >> Counselor Caldwell. >> Yes. >> Counselor Saunders. >> Yes. >> Counselor Hazelton Theo. >> Absolutely yes. >> Counselor Elliot. >> Yes. >> Counselor Lapworth. >> Yes. >> Counselor Longo. >> Yes. >> Mayor Noll. >> Yes. >> Counselor Grant. >> Yes. >> Counselor Wubbenhorst. >> Yes. >> Counselor Adams. >> Yes. >> Counselor Lischna. >> Yes. >> Counselor Nanda. >> Yes. >> Counselor Shi. >> Yes. >> That carries. >> Thank you very much. I'll hand the chair back to you Mayor Noll. >> Well, thank you very much council. I think we've uh we've done something really special tonight. So thank you for your unanimous support. Thank you Counselor Hazelton for seconding the motion. Um I'm I guess everybody's wondering what's next. So what the next steps are we're going to convey this motion to the province. Uh I want to get together quickly with We Love Oakville to talk about uh uh the team Oakville approach and with our ward uh three counselors and uh stay tuned. Uh we'll keep you apprised every step of the way. Okay, members of council, I would like to draw your attention to the fact that we have a confidential item on the agenda with this related to this that is item 6.1. Does anybody want to go into camera to discuss this matter? No? Can I get a motion to receive the confidential report, please? Thank you, Councillor Saunders, and who else is going to Thank you, Councillor Grant. All in favor? That is carried. Okay, we are rounding the bend here to the end of our meeting. The next is a motion to consider the reading of the bylaws. It's bylaw 2026 161 a bylaw to confirm the proceedings of a special meeting of council held this day. Can I get a motion to approve that, please? Thank you, Councillor Shia. Did I get it right? Excellent. Thank you. Seconded by Councillor Hazatheel. All in favor? That is carried. Okay, last but not least, a motion to adjourn tonight's meeting. Councillor Lapworth, Councillor Longo. All in favor? This meeting is adjourned. Thank you so much for being here tonight. [music] >> Recording stopped. [applause] >> Please don't count on every meeting being this short. [laughter]