← Back to summary
Full Transcript
Grimsby Committee Approves Six Property Variances - 17 Nov 26
Grimsby · November 19, 2026
Recording in progress.
>> Uh maybe later.
Yep.
Good evening everyone. I'd like to call
this meeting to order for committee of
adjustment November 17th, 2026.
Uh the committee members in attendance
this evening are Fay Billing,
Kevin Antonitus.
Adam Modder's head is online. Dylan
Bailey still may come. We're sure.
Um, and myself, Daniel Collins.
Staff members present this evening are
Walter Basic, the manager of
community planning. Wing Poo is our
technical support specialist, and Del
Hera Abby Wardena is the secretary
treasurer.
Members of the public are advised that
our meetings are live streamed by the
town of Grimsby.
Individually individuals and media may
be audibly and or visually recorded
during this meeting.
As a reminder, all the electronic
devices are to be in silent mode during
our committee.
I'm going to give an overview of the how
it works, the procedures for committee
of adjustments, and then the committee
has just a little bit of busy work, and
after that we're going to get into
hearing the
the files that we have today.
So for an overview,
the purpose of the application and
relative correspondence will be heard,
following which the applicants will be
given the opportunity to address the
application.
[snorts]
Any person concerned with the
application will then be given an
opportunity to speak.
At the conclusion of the discussion, the
committee will render a decision and
advise of any applicable
conditions.
Copies of the decisions will be made
will be mailed to the applicant or agent
and to any other person who files a
written request.
To request a copy of the decision,
please email Del Hera Abby Wardena, the
secretary treasurer at coa at Grimsby
dot ca.
The applicants, the town of Grimsby, the
minister, or a specified person or
public body has the right to appeal
either the decision itself or the
conditions of consent to the Ontario
Land Tribunal, the OLT, within 20 days
of date of giving notice under
sub-sub-subsection
17
um if completed for consent application
and within 20 days of the date of
decision for a minor variance
application.
Specified persons and certain public
bodies include public utilities but do
not include an individual or community
association.
Everyone present will be given an
opportunity to comment on the
applications being heard.
Please address your comments and
questions through me, the chair.
Each each participant will be provided
with 5 minutes to speak. Each
participant may only speak once. If you
hear your comment presented by someone
else, please do not duplicate the
remarks. When you are called, we ask
that you state your name and address for
the record.
Agencies commenting on applications may
request that certain conditions be
imposed.
Voicing objections to these conditions
will not adversely affect the
committee's decision.
All members of the committee have viewed
the properties on the agenda tonight and
are familiar with the lands that are
subject to the applications.
As you come up to speak um
when it's your turn, you're called up,
we ask that you come up to the lectern
and speak into the microphone.
Uh for the folks that are online and for
the live streaming, it's best that we
have communication always through the
microphones and not across the room.
Now to the committee,
do any committee members have pecuniary
interests with respect to the
applications that are before us this
evening?
No, I see none.
We will now consider the adoption of the
the agenda for this evening. Would
someone please make a motion to adopt
the agenda as presented? Okay, thank
you.
And can I have a seconder on that,
Kevin?
And we'll take a vote on All in favor,
raise your hand.
I see none opposed. That's carried.
Are there any requests for withdrawal or
adjournment?
>> No, Mr. Chair.
>> Thank you.
Have committee members had the
opportunity to review the minutes from
September 15th, 2026? Are there any
questions or comments about the minutes?
I see none. Can I have a mover
to approve the minutes? Thank you, Adam.
And a seconder.
Okay, thank you.
We'll vote on this. All in favor, raise
your hand.
I see none opposed. That is carried.
Tonight we have six applications before
us.
The first application we're going to
hear is A 1926
for 47 Stewart Street. And I'll turn it
over to the secretary treasurer to
present.
>> Thank you, Mr. Chair.
So the purpose of this application is to
build a new detached garage large enough
for vehicle parking and seasonal
storage.
The variance is requested are to permit
a minimum exterior side yard setback of
0.45 m
whereas a minimum exterior side yard
setback of 6 m is required
and to permit a maximum lot coverage of
16% whereas a maximum lot coverage of
15% is permitted.
This is an image of the site plan which
was circulated along with the notice of
hearing.
This is an image of the neighborhood for
context.
These are the current conditions on
site.
And these are the agencies that have
responded with comments or the lack
thereof, and I will summarize those
comments for you now.
Planning staff recommend approval of
minor variance application A1926
as the requested variances are
considered to be minor in nature,
appropriate for the development or use
of the land, building, or structure, and
are considered to maintain the general
intent and purpose of the bylaw and the
official plan pursuant to subsection
45(1) of the Planning Act.
No comments or objections were received
from development engineering staff,
heritage planning staff,
the region, NPCA, or NEC.
Back to you, Mr. Chair.
>> [snorts]
>> Thank you. Is the owner or their agent
here? Yep. Could you come up to the
lectern and just kind of speak to why
you would like the variance, please?
>> [clears throat]
>> Uh good evening.
The variance
>> Oh, I'm sorry. Could you just also state
your name and address for the record?
Thank you.
>> I'm Troy Hauser, and I'm at 47 Stewart
Street, Grimsby.
And we're looking for the variance to
build a detached garage
at the end of our driveway.
So the variance
is required to align the garage with the
with the end of the existing driveway.
>> Okay, thank you. Are there any questions
from the committee?
I see none. Is there anyone in the
public that would like to comment on
this?
I see none. Does the committee
have a
a resolution
or a motion?
Yeah, go ahead, Fay.
>> Through you, Chair. This time I'd like
to make a motion to approve this.
And um
let it be resolved that minor variance
application A19-26
for 47 Stewart Street
to permit a minimum exterior side yard
setback of 0.45 m
whereas a minimum exterior side back set
side yard setback of 6 m is required
according to section 4.18 table two
zoning as amended and to permit a
maximum lot coverage of 16% whereas a
maximum lot coverage of 15% is permitted
according to section 4.18
section seven table 11 and zoning bylaw
14-45 as amended be approved.
Um
meets the four tests minor in nature
desirable use of land fits the scale of
the neighborhood. I have no problems
with this project at all.
>> Okay, thank you. Do I have a seconder on
that motion? Kevin, thank you.
And let's put that to a vote. All in
favor raise your hand.
I see no one opposed, so that is
carried. But just note there's a 20-day
appeal period before it becomes binding.
Thank you.
The next application we have is a A2026
uh for 243 Central Ave. I'll turn it
over to the uh secretary treasurer.
>> Thank you, Mr. Chair.
So the purpose of this application is to
legalize a pool, pool deck, and pool
equipment that is already constructed.
The variance requested is to permit a
setback of 0.38 m from the side lot line
for the pool, deck, and pool equipment
whereas a setback of 1.2 meters is
required from the rear or side lot line.
And this is an image of the site plan
which was circulated along with the
notice of hearing.
This is an image of the neighborhood for
context.
These are the current conditions on
site.
And these are the agencies that have
provided comments and I will summarize
those for you now.
Planning staff
recommend approval
subject to the fine following conditions
that the current built setback of the
above ground pool be maintained and that
a privacy screen be installed to
minimize overlook concerns
along the portion of the deck adjacent
to the easterly side lot line from the
deck floor to a maximum height of 2
meters above the deck floor.
No further comments or objections have
been received from development
engineering staff, heritage planning
staff, the region, NPCA or NEC.
Back to you Mr. Chair.
>> Thank you. Is the applicant or their
agent here?
Yep, could you come up to the lectern,
state your name and address for the
record and then just speak to why you
are asking for this variance?
>> Good evening. I'm for the record. I'm
Matt Marr, 243 Central Avenue, Grimsby.
Yes, so the variance clearly is
required. The deck I have already
constructed.
The pool permit was obtained
in 2025,
summer of 2025. Before building the
pool, I did have the deck on the plan.
Was suggested to remove the deck.
Emailed in February to follow up with
drawings as well. No response. I
continued to build the deck.
To believed
uh to put the bylaws into the code.
Um but clearly not.
Uh it's what I found. So I'm
uh willing to work with the uh planning
from Grimsby and uh hopefully rectify
what needs to get done.
>> Okay, thank you. Are there any questions
from the committee?
Uh I see none. Is there anyone in the
public that would like to speak to this?
Yeah.
Um so I'll just have you sit down if you
don't mind.
Um and I saw you
Oh are those mics working?
Uh Wing? Yeah, okay, never mind.
We'll we'll wait to see if there's a
question, but it uh just behind you uh
would you like to come up to the
microphone to my left?
Yeah.
And if you just want to state your name
and address for the record.
>> Uh my name's Gary Krause. I'm at 14
Trillium Court
directly behind uh Mr. Amar's pool.
And I guess I have a few questions.
Um are you allowed to build a pool deck
with no permit and
just keep it there?
And also I've got concerns about the
height of it. It's it's right to the top
of the fence and he is looking right
into my bedroom window. I mean this far
away.
So and also if you measure from the back
lot line
to his deck
it is closer than the stated
47 in in a few spots. Not by much, but
it is.
It is not 47 in.
>> Okay. Um so those two questions I can
you build a deck without a permit?
Um
and I'm yeah, no.
Um the right permit's required. Uh
there's a process and I think that why
we're here, uh kind of go through this
process now.
And then as to the the question of being
closer to the property line,
that is on the owner.
So if it is found that
it's closer than what has been applied
for, then there's
would be a reapplication.
Is that right, Walter?
Just saying just explaining that if if
it happens that the the pool deck and
pool is closer to the boundary than what
is shown on the drawing, that would be a
reapplication
in the future.
>> Yes, that is correct.
>> Okay.
Do you have further questions?
>> Oh, sorry. Is there a restriction on the
height also? Has that been looked at?
And was was the pool built with a permit
though? I'm I'm not clear on that.
>> Okay, hold on. I'll just put your mic
on. And just yeah, address through me.
I'll I'll ask. No, that's okay.
>> It's okay.
>> Okay, so yeah, to the permit question,
the pool was built with a permit. The
deck was not built with the permit. That
correct?
And we're here to kind of
rectify that issue.
Walter, if I may,
are there
height restrictions
for the deck itself as far as the bylaws
or the zoning?
>> Yeah, there are no height restrictions
for the deck per se.
They are required to be a certain
distance from the lot line. That's
that's based that's the nature of the
application.
It's it's my understanding that it's
only the easterly side yard that's too
close based on the zoning requirements.
And also just in case the question comes
up and I'm speaking, there there's no
height requirement for screening. The
border fencing, there's a height
requirement of 2 m.
But for screens, there there isn't a
height requirement for that.
>> [snorts]
>> Okay, thank you.
So so what? Can you explain to me what
happens if you don't build it with a
permit cuz
does that mean you can just build
whatever you want and then just have a
meeting like this and try to say, you
know, please forgive me? Is that how it
works?
>> Uh that's a good question. That'd be uh
a question Walter be able to take that?
>> Um I I believe there are different fees
required for um if something has already
been built and a permit is is applied
for afterwards. Um I think the fees are
higher for the and there's also the the
the fee associated with the construction
with having to apply for a variance,
which is I think $1,700 or $1,800 or
something like that.
So so there are consequences. Um there
there's also the risk that it it's not
approved then if it's not approved then
there's a risk that you have to take
down the work that you've done.
>> Thank you.
That you good for now?
>> Yeah, I just know that I have other
properties and I know uh if you build it
without a permit it's coming down and
that's what they they very strict
policies that you build without a permit
cuz you know you need a permit
they force you to take it down, start
from scratch. That's and I believe
that's the way it should be.
>> Okay. Yeah.
>> what's the point?
>> Yep. Yep, thank you for your comment.
That's noted.
Uh there was someone else uh yeah,
please uh if you want to take that spot
and then state your name and address for
the record.
>> Hi, I'm Bob Wojcik, the homeowner to the
east.
Um yes, I also have a concern about the
height.
>> Sorry, if you could just uh give your
address as
>> Uh 245 Central Ave.
>> 245 Central.
>> Thank you.
>> And the privacy
of
the fence or the deck is probably 10 20
inches from the property line.
And I see there's a privacy screen
that's been suggested.
Is that going to be a solid privacy
screen from the deck to the two meters
if the deck is approved not to be
removed?
And is there a deadline for this to be
done?
>> Yeah, thank you. I'm going to go to town
staff as well for this. Is it a
specified privacy screen that it's
solid?
And yeah, the
timeline.
>> Um [sighs]
the recommendation wasn't for solid
privacy screen, but that could be
consideration for the committee
to amend the recommended resolution
to require it to be a privacy screen.
And
we only
recommended the installation of a
privacy screen along the easterly
lot line.
I noticed there are
substantial
posts that have been installed along the
northerly lot line or the northerly
portion of the deck also. So there's
there's obviously the ability to put
screening there too if necessary.
Um
so that's again for it's not something
we recommended
because it was a side of the
residential unit that it was abutting.
We didn't feel there was a significant
overlook impact to the north.
But we we do think there's a significant
overlook impact potentially to the east.
Um but not severely significant because
if the deck complied with the setback
provisions, there would still be an
overlook impact.
It's just that it's closer.
So there's a slight slightly greater
overlook impact than if it was built to
zoning standards.
So but it again, I leave it open to the
to the committee to consider uh what
type of screening would be appropriate
if if it feels [clears throat] it's
necessary to
uh modify that condition uh based on the
evidence that's submitted at the at the
committee meeting today.
>> Um then just one more follow-up
question.
As we are looking at uh
side yard setback for the variance, um
if
the pool complied
to 1.2 m
as a setback on the side, there would be
no requirement for privacy fence towards
the north. Is that correct?
>> The um the
I believe it's only the side yard that's
um
deficient from the requirement of the
zoning bylaw and not the northerly yard.
Um so the northerly yard yard complies.
Um
because there is a variance, there's an
opportunity for the committee to impose
any conditions it feels are necessary
or inappropriate for the nature of the
application.
Um
we felt it only appropriate to the
easterly side yard because that's where
the variance is
and that's where we feel uh the the most
significant overlook impact is.
>> Okay, thank you.
Um yeah, go ahead.
>> Uh so the intent uh there are the large
8 ft 4 x 4 posts. So the intent was to
put the privacy panels up
uh either louvered or fence board
horizontally uh put up with minor gap
like 3/4 to 1 in.
Um I could definitely change that design
to go full privacy wall,
take away the guard rails, but
yeah, I'm easy.
>> Okay, [snorts] thank you. Um you you
have any more, Dad?
>> Can I get the extended also to the south
side of that cuz it's still within that
variance
uh to the pool that that should be
privacy also cuz it's
>> Okay, that's something for the committee
to consider that we we you're suggesting
that it wraps around the the south side.
>> Yeah, yeah, yeah, around the corner.
>> you mean.
>> Yeah, cuz it's still within the variance
of 1.
uh
>> Right.
>> 5 meters.
>> Yeah, currently as I'm looking at a
picture, currently it shows that there's
a guard rail there right now, about 4 ft
guard rail. So you're suggesting that
become privacy as well.
>> Cuz that's still within that
measurement.
>> Okay.
Um is there anyone in the public else
that would like to speak to this?
Would you like to come back up? Yeah,
just come to the mic, please.
>> Yeah, I didn't know that this privacy
screening was not going to be all the
way around the back. Like I'm on the
north side
and from where the pool is, I'm my
bedroom window is 8 ft away
from the back of that pool deck. So in
my estimation, anyone who needs privacy
screening would be on that
north what you're saying north facing or
a south side of the pool
uh definitely because
otherwise I open my window and I'm I'm
like on the deck with them pretty much.
So
>> Right. Yeah.
Um yeah, like
>> I keep it I keep it closed now, but that
doesn't mean like why should I have to
keep my
my blinds closed all the time because of
that, you know?
>> Yep. Yeah, for sure. And what I was
alluding to with my question to Walter
was that if this complied, we would have
no power to put a privacy fence up.
But because it doesn't comply with
zoning, we can add that as a condition
that the north side also include uh
privacy fence.
Um
yeah, so there wouldn't be our our
opportunity even the building inspector
wouldn't have the opportunity to add
privacy unless a variance was sought
for.
>> Mhm.
I understand.
>> Yep.
Uh is there anyone else in the public
that would like to speak to this? Uh Uh
about the committee? I'll put it to the
committee.
Yeah, go ahead Fay.
>> Uh
>> Uh through your chair. Um this is for
Delara. Can I see the screenshot of the
um aerial view of the properties,
please?
And did the two neighbors bring any
photos of what they view from their
backyard?
>> Okay, before we do, everybody needs to
see it. So I don't think that's going to
be possible.
Uh if you could uh could they email it
to Delara and pull it up?
Yeah. Yeah, cuz everyone has to be able
to see the pictures.
What email would you like to use? COA?
>> COA.
>> If you could email it to uh COA
uh
find it here.
Uh COA at grimsby.ca.
Okay, while we're waiting to see the
aerial view and have some email sent in,
um any other questions from committee
right now?
Or are we okay to wait for this?
Nothing for Madam?
Okay.
Yeah, you want to come up? I just need
you to come to the
Sorry sorry, you have to speak to the
mic just for folks online um and then
state your name and address for the
record as well.
>> Nancy Myers, 2 Trillium Court um which
is just down the street from my neighbor
here that abuts to this property. The
aerial view that you've got is outdated.
Very much outdated because if you look
two properties over, to the east, there
is a gigantic garage
and lean-to and multiple
free-standing structures.
So this is what we're putting up with
and our resale values have gone down.
The one person abutting to the one two
doors down is having a very tough time
selling the property.
>> Okay, thank you.
>> If I may, Chair, um the the uh Google
Maps image does show the pool and the
deck.
So if uh if uh
Ms. Abriware Denay uh can pull up Google
Maps, she'll be able to illustrate
>> Okay, thank you.
>> uh and the uh
and the construction that was done.
>> Okay.
>> [snorts]
>> There it is.
There it is.
>> Okay, I'll turn it over to Faye for your
question with the uh
aerial view.
>> Okay.
Thank you through the chair.
So that's the pool I'm looking at the
Okay.
>> Sorry, I'm just hearing that it's not
current from the public.
>> Oh, that's not current? Is that the
pool?
>> you can't you can't speak from the
chairs. You have to come up to the
lectern. Sorry for the back and forth,
but just for folks online.
Um
>> If if I may, that's that's the most
current aerial photography that we have.
Um
so if it's aerial photography that you
want to see, that's
that'll be as current as it gets.
>> Yeah.
>> It may not show the garage that the that
the lady is referencing,
but it does show the pool and the deck
around.
>> I think I wanted to see it in reference
to where it lays beside
in in
um conjunction with the neighbor next
door, the two properties next door.
That's what I wanted to see. That that
shows me enough because that's the
that's your pool, right?
>> if you could zoom in a little bit more
into that pool. Yes, there it is there.
>> Okay, so I see a it's at the back. And
when I zoom my site level
>> Unfortunately, it doesn't show the deck
at the back.
>> Right.
>> But the lighter area is generally the
outline of where the deck is.
>> Okay, so to the right there's a garden.
I actually I
I think I saw that garden when I was
my did my site visit.
All right, that's great. Thank you.
>> Okay, any further questions from the
committee?
>> Through your chair, I have one more. I
just wanted to clarify um
when we make a motion, we are adding a
condition of the two screens. Is that
what we're saying? South and north?
>> Okay.
>> Yeah, whoever makes the condition can
add in and and see
um as we go if if there's a secondary.
Um but what has been requested is that
there's a north, there's a south, and
there's an east privacy fence on the
deck.
>> Can I add
that that was the intent to do the north
and
partially east and west, but now going
forward it'll be the whole thing. It'll
be all screened in.
>> Okay.
>> Not screened, but it'll be
uh wood.
>> Wood privacy fencing.
>> Yes.
>> Sorry, through the chair. So directly a
question to you Mr. Mark. So you're
willing to put a privacy fence up to
you know in in helping out what your
neighbors are saying. It's sort of
um obscuring their view, but the privacy
fence will help. So you're willing to do
that?
>> Yes.
>> Okay. Thank you.
>> Um anything else from the committee?
Are we ready with the decision?
Uh do we want to are we still working on
pictures actually?
>> Yeah, I haven't received the email yet.
Have you sent it already?
>> [clears throat]
>> Mr. Chair, I have a question.
>> Yeah, go ahead. Give it give it that uh
the um member is proposing a a condition
to provide screening and the applicant
is willing to provide the screening. Is
it necessary to see the photographs or
>> Yeah.
>> I'm asking. Just [clears throat] asking.
>> I I agree with you. I was thinking the
same thing. Committee Kevin, you were uh
>> Yeah, I would I would
>> I'm I'm in a position to make a motion
without seeing the additional
photographs given that we've got some
agreement between the parties to put the
privacy fence along the entire length of
the deck like the east and the north.
Um
>> Okay. We have one more from the
uh the public. If you could state your
name and address for the record. Thank
you.
>> Yeah. Hi, it's Greg Myers from 2
Taberner. Have one question for the
installation of the deck. Why is it so
high off the ground
from the
from the basically the grade
to the top of the deck and then to go 2
m higher?
It's it's extremely high. His water
level looks to be about 24 in off the
top of the deck down.
Why is the deck so high to begin with,
the platform itself?
>> I'll put that to the uh applicant.
>> That's all.
Uh so the deck is at the same height as
the pool walls. Um there is a grade in
the backyard as well going into the
fence. It dips quite a bit there.
Um so
the deck is quite large. Yes, it is
large. We have kids, neighbors come
over. There's a lot of people on the
deck.
Um the privacy panel was going up and
then we were told to just put it on a
hold.
Um so currently yeah, that's the height
it is. Uh I wasn't told there was a
restriction on the height, so that why I
made it flush.
It's for the safety of the kids so that
they can go in the pool from the top of
the deck, not to worry about tripping in
and around it. Um
yes, the guard rails are up there for
their their safety too. The privacy
fence will do the same thing. It'll
protect the kids from falling out.
>> Okay, thank you.
Uh yeah, if you'd like to come. Thank
you.
>> [clears throat]
>> My name's Christine Turner. I live right
next door to Gary at uh 12 Tobinia.
We're discussing a privacy fence. The
act- that actual deck is level with our
fence that goes on the long side of our
townhouses.
So you've got like a stage.
And what I'm going to dispute is you're
already saying
that it's re- I think Gary said um Gary
and Greg said
it's still too close
to that fence that is
bordering Gary's
um house.
If it's still too close, why is it being
built?
It shouldn't be built if it's too close.
And it is. It's just like looks like a
stage.
>> Okay, thank you for your comment.
Um from yeah from what I under- Oh, go
ahead, Kevin.
>> I was going to ask a question just
through staff.
Just to confirm the rear yard setback is
does meet the bylaw, right? The the deck
is 1.2 m from the rear lot line as we
understand it. So that is permitted
at that height.
Just wanted clarification from staff.
>> Thank you. The measurement that was
provided on the plan uh meets the
requirements of the zoning bylaw for
setback for a deck.
>> Okay, thank you.
>> Yeah, go ahead.
>> actually measured that? I know it's on
the plan, but that's not what it is in
reality.
>> Uh does town staff uh do a site measure
of these
>> Um we're we're not surveyors.
The location of the fence um
may or may not be on the lot line.
Um
the application um is essentially a
swore- sworn statement that
the information provided on
the application is true
to the best of their knowledge,
and that's what [clears throat] we go
by.
Thank you.
>> Okay, thank you.
>> I'll add that the town staff did come
over when the complaint was put forward
and they measured up everything.
>> Okay. Yep.
Go ahead, Walter. You can say.
>> Yeah, that was file on enforcement
staff. Um,
provided measurements again to the
fence, but the location of the fence
isn't always on the lot line.
So I just caution that.
>> Okay. Thank you.
Your mic's on, Yimou.
Did did you get the picture?
Well, we're going to
with regard to the pictures, we're going
to just
I think the committee has enough
information and I want to put it to the
committee if there is a a decision that
you like to put forward, we can
have we can hear that. Is there anyone
that has that decision?
Or do you want to see pictures?
>> [clears throat]
>> I'm just going to wait until just one
more check.
>> Is it just one more check?
>> For the pictures, no, I don't have them
yet.
>> Okay.
Okay.
Does someone in the committee want to
make a motion?
Yeah, Adam. Go ahead.
>> Thank you through Mr. Chair.
I'd like to make a motion to
approve this.
So it'd be resolved that minor variance
application 820 sorry, approve it with
conditions 82-26 for 243 Central Avenue
to permit a setback of 0.38 m from the
side
lot line for the pool deck and pool
equipment
whereas a setback of 1.2 m is required
from the rear or side lot line according
to section 4.10B
in zoning bylaw 1445 as amended be
approved with conditions and the
conditions are one that the current
built setback of the ground above ground
pool being maintained. Two
that the privacy screen be installed to
minimize overlook concerns
along the portion of the deck adjacent
to the north and easterly side lot line
for the deck floor to a maximum height
of 2 m above the deck floor.
Thank you.
>> Okay. You're not adding south on that?
Yeah, cuz one of the requests from I go
ahead.
>> I'd caution the committee to be careful
in that regard with the that condition
because the south is the boundary
between the pool itself and the deck.
>> Okay. Be a a portion.
>> if you're referencing the south.
>> Yep.
Um are you okay to to keep your motion
as is? Like we have a verbal agreement
from the applicant that a south
privacy screen is going to be put up
uh for a portion of it.
>> Well, they just want the north, south,
and east then.
>> Uh well, it the south is tricky like
Walter was saying because that's the the
side the pool is.
Um and so do you want to keep are you
keeping your motion as north and eastern
only?
>> I would I would say just the north and
the east cuz to the west there's a large
tree
that will block everything and from the
south
I think for safety we'd want to you know
homeowners want to see what's going on
at the pool.
>> Okay. [snorts]
Uh do we have a seconder for that then?
Okay.
Okay. We'll put this to a vote. All in
favor, raise your hand.
Any opposed?
Okay. So that is carried.
Uh so you note that there's a 20-day
appeal period before that becomes
binding.
So it's been approved.
Thank you.
Okay. So we're going to move on to the
next application and I'd like to make a
friendly adjustment to our agenda if
possible. There's some toddlers in the
room, and I know bedtime is approaching
soonish. So, what application are you
here for?
>> 364
>> 364
uh Lake, 364 Lake.
Yeah.
If it's okay with the committee, I would
like to move to uh
adjust the agenda that we go to 364 Lake
Street.
Yeah, all in favor?
Okay. Yeah, good. Okay, no problem.
So then I'll turn it over to the
secretary treasurer for 824 26 for 364
Lake Street.
>> Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just a minute
until I get um
situated here.
So the purpose of this application
is to um
Sorry, I'm wondering why it didn't um
Okay.
Uh to permit the installation of a wider
garage door and a wider driveway onto a
building that is currently under
construction.
The variances requested are to permit a
garage door width of 67% of the total
building width,
whereas a maximum garage door width of
50% of the total building width is
permitted for attached garages
associated with residential use that are
assessed um sorry, accessed only by a
driveway from the street.
And to permit a driveway with a 5.31 m,
whereas a driveway with a 4.6 m is
permitted
for a driveway providing access to an
attached garage that is accessed only by
a street for lots having a lot frontage
between
9 m and less than 11 m.
This is an image of the site plan which
was circulated along with the notice of
hearing.
Um this is an image of the neighborhood
for context.
These are the current conditions on
site.
Um this is an image of what is proposed
and these are the agencies that have
provided comments which I will summarize
for you now.
Planning staff recommend approval of
minor variance application A 24 26 as
the requested variances are considered
to be minor in nature, appropriate for
the development or use of the land,
building or structure
and are considered to maintain the
general intent and purpose of the zoning
bylaw and the official plan pursuant to
subsection 45 1 of the Planning Act.
The Niagara Escarpment Commission has no
comments. The subject lands are located
outside of the Niagara Escarpment
planning area and area of development
control.
The NPCA has no comments. There are no
NPCA regulated features on the subject
lands
and no further comments or objections
were received from development
engineering, heritage planning or the
region.
Back to you Mr. Chair.
>> Thank you. Is the
um
agent here to speak to the application?
>> Yep.
>> Good. Thank you.
Presentation is out.
Can we just go back to the first slide?
That's okay.
>> Uh before we begin, if you just wanted
to state your name and address.
>> Uh sure. It's uh Daniel Borelli. And
I'll give you the business address. It's
uh 430 McNelly Road in Stoney Creek.
>> Okay. Thank you.
>> Great. Uh so good evening, committee. Uh
my name is Daniel Borelli and I'm a
planner, project coordinator with uh
Losani Homes.
[clears throat]
I am here tonight respecting minor
variance application A24-26
at 364 Lake Street.
I have reviewed the staff report and I
agree with staff's recommendations.
Um I'll try to keep my comments brief
tonight.
Um if we can just go to the second
slide.
Uh community context. So uh the site is
located on the north side of the QEW. Uh
it's near the eastern municipal
boundary.
The site measures nine nine and a half
meters wide, 49 and a half meters deep,
and has an area of approximately 468
square meters.
The site is designated as low density
residential in the town of Grimsby's
official plan
and is zoned residential detached too.
Residential uses prevail in the
surrounding area and consists mostly of
single detached and townhouse dwellings.
Subject lands are shown in red
uh where a zoning compliant single
detached home is currently under
construction.
If we can just hit the next slide.
Requested variances. Um so the requested
variances are are put up there on the
slide as written in the staff report uh
with arrows pointing to exactly what the
relief is. Uh the areas in green are
just shown as landscaped areas that will
landscaping in the future and and you'll
see that on a separate slide.
[clears throat] The requested variances
seek relief to permit a maximum driveway
width of 5.31 m and to permit a maximum
garage door width of 67% of the total
building width, not a lot width, but a
building width.
The requested variances are minor and
technical in nature.
The variances are due in part to the
lot's characteristics as noted in the
staff report.
However, as you will see in slide five,
the architectural elements of the home
architectural elements of the home have
been included
so that the garage isn't the primary
focal point of the home.
The staff report also notes that
increased garage door width and driveway
width are minor and desirable and will
and will lead to increased functionality
of both the garage and driveway for
the home's future residence.
If we can hit the next slide.
So I was out on site yesterday, took a
few photos. There was
people working on site, but
grabbed the best photos that I could.
And so as you can see that opening there
is the 67%
of the building width, so the where the
garage door will be. And then at the
front property line, that gravelled area
is approximately 5.31 m
or just short of it. We're asking for
the 5.31 m.
And then the next slide.
So this image here was basically using
that previous photo and then the
rendering that we included with the
initial submission a few months back.
It's AI generated. So
take it for what it is, but that's kind
of representing what the home will look
like when it's all done
and fully constructed.
So yeah, thank you and if you have any
comments, I'm here.
>> Okay, thank you. Are there any questions
from the committee?
I see none. Are there anyone in the
public that would like to speak to this?
Is there no anyone online?
Yeah, Paul Fay. Go ahead, Fay.
>> Um through your chair, I just have a
question for you. Actually, the house
looks great. You guys did a great job.
Um it's there is one condition and I
don't know if you covered it. Um S.
Llewellyn and Associates suggested that
the driveway
um the right-of-way
sort of narrow down because of at the
bottom, I guess there's a a swale or
some some Is that what you're planning
to do?
Is that what that drawing was showing?
>> Yeah, so um
in in that letter there's uh
if you go to site, you'll see that it's
already serviced um and that uh
the portion near the road is already
constructed, the culverts and what not.
So we're not looking at modifying that.
It's just everything internal to the
site. So basically we'll flare it out.
So there's the road cut and then the
driveway will just be a little bit wider
so that you can get
sort of a second car on the driveway. Um
the garage isn't wide enough for two
cars, but so one and a half. So if you
get your car and maybe a snow blower and
few recycling bins, that's that's the
intent.
>> Okay. That's I just wanted to clarify
that point. I'm I'm fine with that.
Thank you. Thank you, chair.
>> Okay. Any other questions from
committee?
Do we have a decision?
Yeah, if you want to state your decision
with the reasons.
Go ahead, Fay.
>> Oh.
Through your chair, um
I think everything looks great. I think
this um
meets the four tests. Um the garage is
garage is wider, but the design elements
balance everything out
and he's explained the driveway. So I
would like it to be resolved that minor
variance application A24-26
for a 364 Lake Street to permit a garage
door width of 67% of the total building
width
whereas a maximum garage door width of
50% of the total building width is
permitted for attached garages
associated with a residential use that
accessed only by a driveway from the
street
according to section 4.29 in zoning
bylaw 14-45
as amended and to permit a driveway with
width of 5.31 m whereas a driveway width
of 4.6 m is permitted for a driveway
providing access to the attached garage
that is accessed only by the street for
lots having a lot frontage between 9.0 m
and less than 11.0 m according to
section 4.31 zoning bylaw 1445
be approved with the condition mentioned
about the narrowing at the street
and
I say be approved with that one
condition.
>> Yeah, I don't I don't see a condition on
here. I think that's just the way it's
being built. If I can just get clarity
on that.
>> All right, so just be approved then.
>> Approved no conditions. I see. Okay. Can
I get a seconder on that?
Adam, thank you.
And we'll put this to a vote. All in
favor, raise your hand or say aye.
I see no one opposed. That is carried.
Just note the 20-day appeal period.
You bet.
>> Thanks for the early accommodation.
>> Yeah, of course. You got to get to bed.
Yeah.
Children are always welcome, but
7:50.
Um, next application is A2126 for eight
Orchard Parkway. I'll turn it over to
the secretary treasurer.
>> Thank you, Mr. Chair.
So the purpose of this application um
is to facilitate
the construction of a new accessory
building an addition with a larger
footprint.
The variances requested are to permit a
minimum interior side yard setback of
1.57 m
whereas a minimum interior side yard
setback of 1.8 m is required
and to permit a maximum lot coverage of
27% whereas a maximum lot coverage of
25% is permitted.
This is an image of the site plan which
was circulated along with the notice of
hearing.
And
this is an image of the neighborhood for
context.
These are the current conditions on
site.
And this is
the front elevation of what is proposed.
And these are the agencies that have
provided comments. I will summarize
those comments for you now.
Planning staff recommend approval of
minor variance application A2126
as the requested variances are
considered to be minor in nature,
appropriate for the
development or use of the land, building
or structure and are considered to
maintain the general intent and purpose
of the bylaw and the official plan
pursuant to subsection 45(1) of the
Planning Act.
NPCA says there are no NPCA regulated
features located at on this address at
this time. As such, the NPCA offers
objections to this proposal.
The Niagara escarpment says the subject
property
is located outside of the Niagara
escarpment development control area. As
such, development development permit is
not required from our office.
However, the subject property is located
within the Niagara escarpment plan area
and is designated as urban area by the
Niagara escarpment plan.
As such, the policies within parts 1.7
urban area and two development criteria
of the Niagara escarpment plan apply.
NEC staff understand the proposal is for
demolition and reconstruction of a
patio/deck
and construction of a dwelling addition
and detached accessory building.
Part 1.7.4
states proposed uses
and the creation [clears throat] of new
lots may be permitted subject to
conformity with part two development
criteria,
the development objectives and where
applicable zoning bylaws that are not in
conflict with the Niagara escarpment
plan.
NEC staff have reviewed the proposal and
flow plans and do not note any policy
conflicts with the Niagara escarpment
plan provided the accessory structure
will not be utilized as or contain a
secondary dwelling unit.
Provided the town of Grimsby is
satisfied that the application conforms
to the intent of the official plan and
zoning bylaw, NEC staff have no
objections.
No further comments or objections have
been received from development
engineering staff, heritage planning
staff, or the region. Back to you, Mr.
Chair.
>> Thank you. Is the agent or applicant
here?
>> Hello.
>> Oh.
>> Sorry, I'm just trying to turn on my
my video. Oh, there it is.
>> Yeah, no problem. If you could just
state state your name and address for
the record, please.
>> Yeah. So, I'm Christina Hudson um and my
address is 24 Elm Street in Grimsby.
Um I'm representing the homeowners at
eight Orchard Parkway. Um, so as you
guys mentioned, we're just looking for
the interior side yard setback and then
the maximum lot coverage.
>> Okay, thank you.
Um, any questions from the committee to
begin?
No.
Uh, I have a question. The side yard
setback you're asking, are you matching
existing?
Is the existing um side yard
From what I understand on the drawings,
that's kind of what it looks like to me.
>> Yes. So the accessory building is
matching existing and yes, the addition
is as well. Yeah.
>> Okay. Thank you.
Uh, is there anyone in the public that
would like to speak to this? Yep. If you
want to come to the
lecture, just state your name and
address for the record, please.
>> Hi, my name is Marjorie Hewitt and I'm
from three Peachwood Place.
Um, and so that would be lot 43.
Um, and
it's not that I have um a huge
disagreement with this, but I do have
some questions for the owner about some
of their intentions because
um the back of my house looks out on
their backyard and it's a very park-like
setting and I spend a lot of time, my
family spends a lot of time on the back
of my house kind of looking out at this
setting. So I was um
being unfamiliar with all of these maps
and all that. I just had a couple of
questions. And so I just heard you speak
about uh the shed, like the extra
building. So currently my shed is
directly uh
kind of like in lined up with their
shed. And I was just wondering and which
is perfect, you know, um for me.
But I just wasn't sure whether or not
this new shed was going to be more in my
sight lines and is it going to be
higher? Like is there going to be a
second floor to it?
Anything like that. I also wanted to
know whether the large tree in the
center of their property, which
I have the privilege [clears throat] of
enjoying, whether or not that's going to
be taken down. And I'd like to know
whether the um kind of the frost fence
that divides our properties and has
quite a thick group of cedar trees um
along that fence, whether that will be
removed, just for my own knowledge about
what I'm going to be looking at going
forward.
>> Sure. Um
when it comes to trees, it's a tricky
one because they you know living things
they can come they go uh for sure. But
just your intent of the uh the trees,
especially that cedar. I agree that's a
nice cedar hedge you have between the
houses.
Um is there an intent to remove that? Do
you know at this point?
I'll put that to
>> So there is no intent to remove it.
There's the possibility of having to
remove like one or two in order to build
the um structure in the back, but we
don't intend to remove it all.
>> Okay. Um now back to the question of uh
the
um
the building, is it going to be a two
story or one story?
>> One story.
>> One story. Okay.
Uh in the same position?
Or or close to the same position of the
old shed?
>> Yeah, so the back and then the right
side along lot 43 that's staying the
same, so nothing's getting any closer.
>> Okay.
Yeah.
Is that okay?
>> Yeah.
>> Just wondering where we were at with it.
>> Sure. Yeah. Um
yeah, that's good. Any other questions
from committee about that?
Yeah, no problem. Thank you Ms. Hewitt.
Anyone else in the public want to speak
to this?
No? Do we have a decision? Yeah, go
ahead Kevin.
>> Yeah, I'll be happy to make a motion on
this having uh
heard the evidence verbally and the
written reports. Um, I'd like to make a
motion to approve this resolved at minor
variance application A2126 for 8 Orchard
Parkway
to permit a minimum interior side yard
setback of 1.57 m whereas a minimum side
yard of 1.8 m is required according to
section 721 of table 11 in zoning bylaw
1445 as amended and to permit a maximum
lot coverage of 27%
whereas a maximum lot coverage of 25% is
permitted as per 721 of table 11 in the
zoning bylaw 1445 as amended.
The reasons being it's minor in nature,
meets the intent of the official plan
and zoning bylaw and is appropriate for
the development use of the property with
no conditions.
>> Thank you. Do I have a seconder?
Fay? Okay.
And we'll put it to a vote. All in
favor, raise your hand.
I see no one opposed. That is carried.
Uh, please note the 20-day appeal period
before it becomes binding.
Thank you.
>> That's good. Thank you.
>> Yep.
Uh, next application is A2226
for 38 Roberts Road. I'll turn it over
to the secretary treasurer to present
the application.
>> Thank you, Mr. Chair.
The purpose of this application is to
enclose the existing unenclosed carport
and add to the existing garage.
The variance is requested to permit a
maximum overall lot coverage of 25%
whereas a maximum overall lot coverage
of as existing is permitted.
To permit a maximum lot coverage of
14.5%
for an accessory building whereas a
maximum lot coverage of 10% is
permitted.
To permit a minimum setback of 0.47 m
from the rear lot line whereas a minimum
setback of 1.3 m from the rear lot line
is required.
And to permit a minimum building height
of 6 m where is the maximum building
height of four and a half meters is
permitted.
This is an image of the site plan which
was circulated along with the notice of
hearing.
This is an image of the neighborhood for
context.
These are the current conditions on
site.
And
this is rendering of the front elevation
for what is proposed.
And these are the agencies that have
provided comments. I will summarize
those comments for you now.
Planning staff recommend approval of
minor variance application A 22 26 as
the requested variances are considered
to be minor in nature,
appropriate for the development or use
of the land, building or structure and
are considered to maintain the general
intent and purpose of the bylaw and the
official plan pursuant to subsection 45
1 of the Planning Act.
Heritage planning has the following
comments. In general, heritage staff are
supportive of the proposed works. The
introduction of this modern layer will
further support the building's long-term
retention.
As part of the heritage review, staff
assessed potential impacts of the
identified cultural heritage value.
It is important to note that there is no
requirement under the Ontario Heritage
Act for the property owner to obtain a
heritage permit.
Within the Ontario Heritage Act, a
heritage permit is only required if the
proposed works are likely to affect a
protected heritage attribute.
None of the protected heritage
attributes will be impacted by the
proposed works. In order to further
mitigate any potential impacts as
outlined within the official plan policy
8.18
and to further support the preservation
of the protected heritage attributes,
conditions have been recommended to
support a proactive strategy
to ensure the historic structure is not
impacted by any adjacent vibration from
construction.
Archaeological commence as of March
31st, 2025, the Niagara official plan is
no longer regional plan. It is now an
official plan for Grimsby.
The provincial planning statement and
Niagara official plan state that
development and site alteration shall
not be permitted within areas of
archaeological potential unless
significant archaeological resources
have been conserved or the land has been
investigated and cleared or mitigated
following clearance from the province.
Chapter six of the NOP states that
where a site proposed for development is
located within an area of archaeological
potential, a stage one to two
archaeological assessment at minimum may
be required.
Based on the proposed works meeting the
scoping considerations within the AMP,
no archaeological assessment is
required.
Within the scoping considerations, it is
recommended that the owner be informed
of the town's archaeological warning
clause.
So these are the
conditions recommended by the heritage
planning staff
to ensure adherence to provincial
policy, to mitigate impacts resulting
from the proposed works and to meet the
intent of the official plan.
That vibration crack monitoring devices
be installed by heritage staff on the
main dwelling and that devices remain on
the building throughout the duration of
construction.
That the final proposed materials be
noted within the elevation submitted
with the building permit and that those
documents be reviewed and approved by
heritage staff
to ensure that the proposed works are in
keeping with the heritage dwelling.
That the owner be informed of the
following advisory clause. If deeply
buried or previously undiscovered
archaeological remains or resources are
found during development activities on
the subject lands, all activities must
stop immediately.
If the discovery [snorts] is human
remains, contact the Niagara Regional
Police Service and Corona to
to secure the site.
If the discovery is not human remains,
the area must be secured to prevent site
disturbance.
The project proponent must then follow
the steps outlined in the archaeological
management plan.
With the
Niagara Escarpment Commission said that
the subject property is located outside
of the Niagara Escarpment plan and area
of development control. As such, they
have no comments on this application.
NPCA said that no NPCA regulated
features are located at this address at
this time. So they have no objections to
this proposal.
Development Engineering and the region
do not have any comments or objections.
An email was received
from
someone in the public at
3:19 p.m. today.
And I will read that email out now.
This is from John A. Klein at
42 Roberts Road.
Dear Committee of Adjustment Members, we
are writing regarding minor variance
application A2226 for a proposed
addition to the existing garage.
We are the owners of 20 of 42 Roberts
Road and the east lot line at the rear
of the subject garage abutting our
property.
We have several concerns regarding the
application.
One, reduced rear yard setback. The
application proposes reducing the rear
yard setback from 1.3 m to 0.47 m
at the southeast corner of the proposed
addition.
This appears unnecessarily close to the
property line, particularly when
combined with the requested increase in
building height
from 4.5 m to 6.5 m.
If the height increase to 6.5 m is
approved, we would strongly prefer that
the standard rear yard setback of 1.3 m
be maintained to lessen the impact on
the neighboring property.
Number two, accuracy of existing setback
information.
Related to the above concern is the
stated rear yard setback of the existing
lean to structure shown on the proposed
site plan.
The application indicates the existing
rear setback is 1.06 m. However,
based on measurements we have taken
using nearby property stakes as
reference points, we estimate the actual
setback to be approximately 0.5 to 0.6
m.
This discrepancy could likely be
confirmed through a survey should one be
available for the property.
If the existing setback is in fact
closer to 0.6 m, the proposed addition
would project approximately 0.4 m
further toward the property line than
the existing structure
resulting in a setback of roughly 0.7 m
rather than the 0.47 m indicated in the
application.
We request that the committee verify
these measurements as part of its
review.
[snorts] Number three, requested
increase in building height. We question
the need for the proposed increase in
building height from 4 and 1/2 m to 6
and 1/2 m.
We assume this is intended to facilitate
a second story of full height upper
level space within the garage addition.
However, this rationale is not stated in
the application materials. We would
appreciate clarification regarding the
purpose and necessity of the additional
height.
Number four, stated use of the garage.
We will assume that the building will
remain a garage for residential use and
not be used for business or as
additional living accommodation.
It is our understanding that living
spaces in secondary buildings or garages
is not permitted in the town of Grimsby.
We respectfully request that the
committee of adjustment consider these
concerns when reviewing this application
and determining whether the requested
variances meet the applicable planning
tests.
Thank you for your consideration, John
and Michelle Klein. Back to you, Mr.
Chair.
>> Okay, thank you. Is the agent or
applicant here?
That's Christina.
>> Yes, hi. I've
>> got my mic with me.
>> Okay. [laughter]
Hello. Um,
yeah, do we're good for name and
address?
>> Yeah.
>> Yep. Okay.
If you want to just state your reasons
for the variances and then I'll get into
some questions from there.
>> Yeah, for sure.
Um, okay. So the first thing we need the
variance some of the variances because
our zone is the existing, so any change
we need we need that. So I think that
kind of touches on the maximum lot
coverage.
Um, we are requesting or we're planning
to enclose the carport just for more
storage and more garage space
and then the storage up above. So
>> Just to touch on that, there's already a
second story storage area up there now,
which we're then just continuing over
across the building.
Um, as for the lot line that he was
concerned about the neighbors,
um,
the plan of the direction and where the
existing garage is now, it's already
closer than what he would want.
So we are just following the line of the
garage itself.
Um, so it's not like we're like jetting
further than it is. We're just trying to
keep so that it's actually going to be
aesthetically pleasing opposed to having
like a weird jog and then a roof line
and
it not be appealing. So that's that's
what we're asking for what we're asking
for.
>> Okay, thank you. And then to the letter
from Mr. Klein, purpose of the height
and purpose of the garage.
If you want to start with purpose of the
garage, it's is it storage? Is it
accessible residential unit?
What's the intent?
>> So the intent is storage
with like maybe like a gym in the side
of it because like they're like outdoors
people and stuff like that. So one of
the bay they have a bunch of cars right
now. They have you know Broncos and
Mustangs and a bunch of nice cars that
they like to park in there and then
they'd like to have
most of their storage up top and then
they like to have the gym on like the
main level kind of like in one of the
bays. So
>> Okay, and then
>> It's not a business. The gym is not a
business. It's a personal home gym.
>> Okay, personal gym noted.
Purpose of the height?
>> Just because with what we have now with
the roof because what is the roof
>> Right, it is a gable right now, but the
ceiling is only like the wall height up
there is only 3 ft.
>> Yeah, so there's a knee wall, so now the
wall's going to actually be taller just
for like a look because we wanted to
achieve like a and like that rendering
is kind of like
it's not what it's going to look like
because we want to do like more of a
roof on the front, so we need to
actually the wall to be taller to make
the roof look nice in front and kind of
that carriage home because it is a
pretty sought after property, I think in
Grimsby and we want to obviously keep it
looking, you know, sharp instead of like
an eye sore.
So that drawing was a very prelim one
that we put in, you know, 3 months ago
and with missing the other variance
meeting or
having one delayed, you know, it could
have changed the
>> Yeah, thank you. Uh I'm going to put it
to the committee for questions.
Yeah, go ahead.
>> Quick question. Um so if I'm looking at
the roof plan from Google Earth for
example, you're effectively just
building the same footprint
that's there, right? But just building
it up to match the existing roof line
height wise,
right? From what I can tell.
I know they came I know they came to
this committee for a variance maybe 10
years ago when they built that carport
um on that side yard.
Um but I thought they did a nice job. It
looks nice and I think the proposed use
kind of continues that.
Um
what about accessory dwelling units?
Like I know everybody says it's just
storage and eventually, but I thought it
was as of right, Walter, is it not
through the chair uh for accessory
dwelling units in urban areas? The
province, I thought, was mandating that.
>> Yeah, it is
uh with the exception of um uh
escarpment urban areas designations
within the Niagara Escarpment Plan. Uh
they're only permitted within the
dwelling, not in in accessory buildings.
>> Does this lie in escarpment urban?
>> It does.
>> Oh, it does. Okay. All right. So that
would uh negate that use.
But yeah, no, I and I think it it looks
good. The proposal looks good. And with
respect to their objections, to be
honest, I look at the size of their
property and the distance from this
house to their house. It's a pretty
large property. So I think the we're not
dealing with the the the couple that was
here earlier and the fence was, you
know, 8 ft from the bedroom. This is a
significant distance from their home. I
think
impact is going to be negligible if any.
So I am uh happy to support this on a
motion when you ask for it.
>> Um any other comments from public?
No. No, I see none.
Um
[snorts]
yeah, it's big. Like I look at uh the
proposed pictures versus the uh
existing photos.
Um
it is a substantial
height, but really for variance, we're
looking at 4 and 1/2 ft roughly, right?
Um yeah, 1.5 m.
I'll put it to the committee. We have uh
Oh, Adam, go ahead.
>> Thank you uh Mr. Chair. Um
generally, I'm happy with the proposal,
but I just have concerns about the
height. Um
I don't know. I
if it visually
challenge the house, especially
considering it's a heritage protected
property. That's kind of the perspective
I'm looking at cuz I think it's a 33
33% increase over what's permitted in
>> Okay, thank you for your comments.
Any other comments from committee?
>> That's it. And then this is existing.
>> Right.
>> There's just a schematic version here.
>> Do you think so?
>> For sure.
>> I think
>> But they're existing now.
>> From the car.
>> From the car port.
>> [clears throat]
>> All right, question to town staff.
There's a dormer on the top. Mid peak is
taken from the dormer or is it taken
from the the major roof line?
>> The midpoint is measured
along the slope of the main roof,
not the dormer.
>> Okay.
Are you prepared to make a motion?
>> Yeah, I am. Okay.
Yeah, having heard the
verbal evidence and the written reports
both from planning staff, but also
heritage planning staff who are in
support of it or not opposed to it
anyways,
and the distance from the neighbor who
was the only one objecting,
I think the impact is minimal. So I can
support this motion as presented.
Resolve that minor variance A 22 26 for
38 Roberts Road to permit a maximum
overall
lot coverage of 25% whereas maximum
overall lot coverage as existing is
permitted according to section 721 table
11 in zoning by 14 45 is amended and to
permit
mit a maximum lot coverage of 14.5% for
an accessory dwelling
or building whereas a maximum lot
coverage of 10% is permitted according
to section 418 table two
in zoning by 14 45 is amended and to
permit a minimum setback of 0.47 m from
the rear lot line whereas a minimum
setback of 1.3 m from the rear lot line
is required according to section 418
table two in zoning by 14 45 is amended
and to permit a maximum building height
of 6 m whereas maximum building height
of 4 and 1/2 m is permitted according to
418 of table two in zoning by 14 45 as
amended be approved with the conditions
as read previously
1 2 and 3 as we read. I'm not going to
read unless you want me to.
>> No, it's okay.
>> Being the reasons being that the the
variance requested are minor nature meet
the intent of the official plan and
zoning bylaw
and is appropriate for the development
and use of the property.
So move.
>> Thank you. Do I have a seconder on that?
Yeah, Fay, you're going to second that?
And we'll put the two to vote. All in
favor, raise your hand.
Any opposed?
I see one. That is carried. Please note
that the 20 day appeal period before it
becomes binding.
Thank you. Thank you.
Um and
our last application for this evening is
A 23 26 for 24 Lake Street. I'll turn it
over to the secretary treasurer for the
presentation.
>> Thank you, Mr. Chair.
So the purpose sorry, the purpose of
this application is to facilitate a roof
in the rear yard for a covered porch.
The variance requested is to permit an
unenclosed canopy to project a distance
of 5.2 m into the required rear yard,
whereas unenclosed canopies may project
into any required rear yard, a distance
of not more than 1 and 1/2 m.
This is an image of the site plan which
was circulated along with the
application.
This is a picture of the neighborhood
for context.
These are the current conditions on
site.
And these are the agencies that have
provided comments.
Planning staff recommend approval of
minor variance application A2326
as the requested variances are
considered to be minor in nature,
appropriate for the development or use
of the land, building or structure, and
are considered to maintain the general
intent and purpose of the bylaw and the
official plan pursuant to subsection 451
of the Planning Act.
Niagara Escarpment Commission
has no comments. The subject lands are
located outside of the Niagara
Escarpment plan area and area of
development control.
The NPCA has no comments either. There
are no NPCA regulated features on the
subject lands, and no further comments
or objections were received from
development engineering, heritage
planning, or the region.
Back to you, Mr. Chair.
>> Thank you. Is the agent or applicant
here? If you could come and
and state your name and address for the
record, please.
>> Hello, my my name is Ramon Villa Franca.
I'm the owner of
24
Lake Street in Grimsby.
Just bought the property back in
May.
And
I've done a little bit of work on it
just to accommodate my wife and I.
I have grandkids.
And I have two great grandkids.
So I need a
a covered porch
in order to
keep the sun out from the backyard.
So I feel that
it's a necessity to
to have
a porch, covered porch.
So that's my aim.
>> Okay, thank you. Any questions from the
committee?
You're the designer? Yeah, okay. That's
good. When I get to public, yeah, you
can speak in favor.
Anything from committee right now?
No?
Are you still going to be able to see
that tree in the backyard with the
covered porch?
>> Yes.
>> Okay, good.
Totally. Okay.
>> The good thing is that
I'm not
it won't be seen from the from the
street.
It won't be seen from
anywhere because
the house that to the if I'm looking at
the house
the house to the to the right
there's no vision to the backyard.
The one on the left
you can't see the
the backyard because of the
my garage covers it.
So I have nobody around. So I'm kind of
secluded.
And
I'm an architect and I
still working.
But so I like to do something unique to
this house and
and
thus
keep my family happy.
>> Yeah, [snorts] for sure. Is there anyone
in the public online that would like to
speak to this?
No. Okay. Does the committee have a
decision?
Adam, go ahead, Adam.
>> Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just a minute. Let
me tab in.
Um
resolve motion be resolved that minor
variance application A2326 for 24 Lake
Street to permit an enclosed canopy
project a distance of 5.2 m
to the required rear yard, whereas
enclosed canopies may project into
any required rear yard a distance of not
more than 1.5 m according to section 4.9
C in zoning bylaw 1445 as amended
be approved without conditions and for
reasons the submission showed that
the
proposal is minor in nature, meets the
intent of the official plan, zoning
bylaw,
is desirable. Thank you.
>> Thank you. Do I have a seconder?
Kevin
Orfe. I have two seconders. I wonder how
this vote's going to go.
Um all
we'll take it to a vote. All in favor,
raise your hand or say aye.
I see no opposed, so that it's carried.
Just note there's the 20-day appeal
period before it becomes binding.
Thank you.
[snorts]
[clears throat]
Uh so the next meeting of committee of
adjustment will be held December 15,
2026.
This meeting is adjourned. Thank you.
>> Recording stopped.